How are the AirPot brewers supposed to be? Sams has this Bunn for $299. I've never had good coffee from a Bunn though.
I recommend that unit, as I purchased it about 2.5 years ago from Sams, and then about a 1 year ago sold it to the place I work.
We use it every day, and it is still going strong. It has a pretty good recovery too (I think something like 3 gallons per hour). It is a pourover, so no plumb-in needed. If you want both, I think Bunn might have a couple of models that give you both plumb-in and pourover, but they might be pricey. And as for the flavor, it is good. On something like this the extraction time is about 4 minutes, which I find good enough (some want more like 6). The only thing we did was buy the big metal gourmet filter basket (called a funnel) as well as the larger filters, since the stock filter basket and filters would overflow with the amount of coffee I like to use, especially since it is very fresh and tends to bloom more. They are not cheap, but I got the funnel and the larger filters from CW-USA, and can highly recommend them. If you are serious about it, please PM me for the actual part numbers, since that was a little tricky.
http://www.cw-usa.com/In any case, for carafes, I like the 2.2 liter (about 1/2 gallon) glass lined Japanese babies like this one:
http://www.amazon.com/Zojirushi-2-Liter-Brew-Thru-Polished-Stainless/dp/B00004S56Q/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&s=home-garden&qid=1208371376&sr=8-3We have 2 of these, and they have withstood the abuse so far, and are pretty easy to clean. Not to mention do a great job keeping your coffee hot for awhile.
Chris