Green Coffee Buying Club

Coffee Discussion boards => Hardware & Equipment => Topic started by: psedillo on October 29, 2008, 05:37:36 AM

Title: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: psedillo on October 29, 2008, 05:37:36 AM

I roast out on my back patio and with the weather getting cooler in Houston (crazy I know) I was wondering if I need to compensate for the drop in temperatures? If so what should I be doing?
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: Mlee on October 29, 2008, 06:18:21 AM
I find myself having to preheat to about the 175-180 mark (instead of the preset beep point of 167)to compensate for the initial heat loss when you drop the beans. Other than that it hums right along. There may be slightly more time between cracks but nothing that really matters. Wind is more of a factor than the cool to me.. Hope that helps

Mike
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: psedillo on October 30, 2008, 12:28:26 PM
I find myself having to preheat to about the 175-180 mark (instead of the preset beep point of 167)to compensate for the initial heat loss when you drop the beans. Other than that it hums right along. There may be slightly more time between cracks but nothing that really matters. Wind is more of a factor than the cool to me.. Hope that helps

Mike

Mike - Thank you for the reply, that is the info I was looking for!
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: 5thumbs on October 30, 2008, 02:47:00 PM
Mike (and others),   How far do you push the lifetime of the Hottop filters (top and side), or do you change them regularly?  I rinse them out once in awhile to "double" the suggested lifetime of them.  Also I pull the back filter partially out after 1st crack, and fully out after once 2nd crack has started and during cooling.   Has not been a problem for me but just wanted to know if you have "pushed the limits" with the filters and if you have noticed any effects.
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: Mlee on October 30, 2008, 05:51:46 PM
I shoot for about 40-50 roasts with the rear filter and about 100-110 with the top one. Really dont notice much difference in letting them go that long.The times and results are pretty consistent...
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: staylor on October 30, 2008, 07:06:39 PM
Hahaha, don't worry too much about the Houston temps (since they are generally the same as Team Sugar Land) it will never get cold enough here to worry about the temps. I used to put my Hottop in stamped down snow (in Canada) and take it up to pre-heat temps of approx 170 and drop the beans in, I could see when things were getting to pre-heat temps based on the radius of melted snow. ;-)

If it got below -20 I would still roast outside and would just choose a windless day and add a few more degrees of pre-heat. I've found wind affected things more than temps, once things get a bit cooler outside. If I needed beans and it was a windy Canadian winter day I would roast in the garage. I've roasted in temps below -40.

As for filters, for the top filter I don't track it by number of roasts, I just look at it top-down while the roaster is roasting and if I can see the roasting element through obvious gaps in the filter material then I reorder a new one, I'd say they last for approx 100 roasts. For the rear filter the Scottish blood in my stretches the life cycle out on that bad boy for A LOT of roasts, once I see an obvious build up of residue on the filter material I boil some water, put a little bit of Cafiza on a deep plate, pour the water on the Cafiza, mix it up and then rest the entire rear filter assembly in the Cafiza'd water. I agitate the water a bit to help release some of the particulates and a couple of minutes later I take the assembly out and use a low pressure jet spray from the sink to get rid of the dirty water - be sure to use really, really low pressure or you will tear the black filter material. Set the whole thing outside in the sun to dry. Wallah, an almost eternally lasting rear filter.
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: cfsheridan on October 30, 2008, 07:27:37 PM
Interesting...

After a few roasts with my hottop, I decided to test out a bit more preheat.  I liked the results, and have stuck with a profile designed around me dropping the beans in at 250? F.

The only annoying thing is that the machine insists on having to go back down to 165?F before starting another cycle.  Every time I roast, it makes me want to install a new control system, but I know where that rabbit hole leads...
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: staylor on October 30, 2008, 10:19:14 PM
I got distracted the other day and missed the pre-heat warning beep and ended up pouring the greens in at 220 or so, I didn't even blink an eye, I don't sweat that stuff too much now, there's thousands of roasts still to come. ;-)  I bet in a year I'll get all OCD about finding "the perfect drop temp for each bean", poor John.

It is a bit annoying having to wait until it gets below 165 so you can start a new roast cycle, I just put the nozzle of my industrial wet/dry vac on top of the green feed chute and reverse blow all the hot air out of the chamber, it gets the temp down pretty quickly as compared to just letting the ambient air do it. Give it a try.
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: Pyment on October 31, 2008, 05:01:38 AM
Are we talking about F or C?

With my Toper I am using Celsius. It has a lot of metal to heat (it weighs in the 130-150 lb range). So if I don't preheat pretty well, I get pretty long profiles because I am heating the steel besides the beans. If I drop at lower temps (under 200 C), I get really long profiles- up to 25-30 min. I haven't scorched beans with temps up to 250C. My first step is to find the drop temp for various beans.

I have come to realize that my bean probe isn't really measuring bean temp with a 1 lb load (what I have been using so far). I think  that early in the curve, It runs closer to environmental and later it is closer to actual bean temp (presumably as volume expands). I am still using visual, smell, and sound to track the roast and am still trying to adjust the probe placement. I want to get it into the bean mass but not touching the drum surface. I may have to sneak a second probe into the bean mass.

I can vary the rate of heating by restricting air flow. I am starting to use pauses at critical temps, but this slows the roast. When I do that, it is hard to regain momentum. I worry about baking the beans.

Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: cfsheridan on October 31, 2008, 06:26:55 AM
All my temps are ?F.  I've dropped as high as 300?F in the hottop with good results.

I put a fan on in front of the machine, and I am usually down to 165?F by the end of the cooling cycle.  Blowing out the chamber with compressed air to clean out the chaff also helps.  That said, it seems silly that I have to go that low, when I'd rather just take the roaster down to 250-300?F for the next roast. 

I remember that the CCR (Computer controlled roaster) hottops that some folks produced took care of this "feature", which is one (among many) of the reasons I'd like to convert this machine (if the bug to get a commercial roaster doesn't give me the tactic to convince my wife first).
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: staylor on October 31, 2008, 06:38:10 AM
Yeah, it is silly that we all have to go back to 165, I'm now in the habit of blowing out the chamber to speed up the drop then wandering over to my green bean closet and weighing out a batch and writing down what I have put together, by then the Hottop is usually at temp again.

Ohhhhhhhh, that commercial roaster bug, I feel your pain. I'm sure my wife would be ok with a "real" roaster purchase but I'm still pretty happy with the Hottop overall.
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: John F on October 31, 2008, 07:05:17 AM
I've roasted in temps below -40

I hope you roasted close to the sled dogs at least to give them a tiny bit of warmth to huddle around.

-40..... unthinkable.

Remind me to make sure it's August whenever I come visit you some day up there in the tundra.

-40.... madness.


John F
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: staylor on October 31, 2008, 07:46:59 AM
No, what's unthinkable is... no coffee. ;-)
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: Pyment on October 31, 2008, 08:13:47 AM
I have to cool my unit to 176F before shutting down to avoid warping the drum. That was probably part of the thinking by the Hottop folks. We don't want the homeroasters warping their drum and having to do a lot of servicing.

I just readjusted my probe again. I found out that it was wrapping around the center axis. It was too long. I have shortened it and will see if this works. I am figuring it needs long enough to be below the trier and short enough that it won't catch one of the vanes and wrap around the middle.

I am warming the drum now to roast 1 kg of a Kenyan. This is actually my first 1 kg roast. All the rest have been 500 grams. I plan to drop at about 235C (~455F) and pause (1 min) between 190C and 200C (~370-390F)  to enhance sweetness.  Then take it through 1st C (227C/440F) hold here 1 min, then take it up to 232C/450F and finish either after a minute here or start of FC whichever comes first. My wife prefers coffe with more sweetness and less acidity.

I am guessing this will be somewhere between 25-30 min.

staylor, When I am ready to move up to a bigger roaster (I have my eye on a USRC 3K), I'll give you a good price on this one. (http://i.imdb.com/Photos/CMSIcons/emoticons/evilgrin/evil9.gif)
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: staylor on October 31, 2008, 08:51:40 AM

staylor, When I am ready to move up to a bigger roaster (I have my eye on a USRC 3K), I'll give you a good price on this one. ([url]http://i.imdb.com/Photos/CMSIcons/emoticons/evilgrin/evil9.gif[/url])


Killin' me. ;-)
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: John F on October 31, 2008, 01:03:28 PM
No, what's unthinkable is... no coffee. ;-)

Build a shed....  :P
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: Pyment on October 31, 2008, 05:23:33 PM
I am thinking sod huts are big in Canada.

(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/33/Saskatchewan_sod_house.jpg)
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: staylor on October 31, 2008, 05:47:32 PM
Awesome. In the image above, it looks like my garage has a chimney to vent the roasting fumes when the temps drop to -80 degrees.
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: Joe on October 31, 2008, 10:17:13 PM

If it got below -20 ...snip... I've roasted in temps below -40.



Is that Canadian degrees? Seriously If I hadn't joined the military which had me moved to New Jersey and stayed in cold places like Alaska in January etc... I would never know what cold weather really means. Sucks.
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: Pyment on October 31, 2008, 10:57:05 PM
Builds character(s)! look at the Cabal. ::)
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: Joe on October 31, 2008, 11:03:34 PM
Builds character(s)! look at the Cabal. ::)

You aint kidding.

B/Java
Rasqual
Masked flying Py
Jeffo
Peter the Great
whom else?
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: Pyment on October 31, 2008, 11:09:18 PM
We've had RonL, 7over and visits from others
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: Joe on October 31, 2008, 11:09:50 PM
Awesome. In the image above, it looks like my garage has a chimney to vent the roasting fumes when the temps drop to -80 degrees.

Uhhh Shaun, I don't think that is a Garage. I think it's a duplex, and the small side is where Grandpa sleeps. They don't have Garages for horse drawn Carriages, they are called "Barns". But I think this picture is actually from Utah very recently, don't let the old clothes and lack of technology fool you.

Joe
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: staylor on November 01, 2008, 04:51:03 AM
Hey, it's my dream home don't go calling it a duplex. I like to think of it as a bungalow with attached garage and a view. ;-)
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: Pyment on November 01, 2008, 06:10:23 AM
It is actually in Saskatchewan. I wouldn't offer staylor a fraud.
 
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: donfo on November 01, 2008, 08:29:04 AM
I'm still roasting in the house...... at least until I get kicked out to the garage. I'm using a Gene Cafe so the smoke has not been too bad. That being said..... snow is part of reality here in Canada.

Don
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: bibletec on November 13, 2008, 02:29:30 PM
I have a question about higher drop temps on the Hottop. How long does it take you to get to 300 F? I thought the standard 6 min was an important point to maintain in the roasting profile.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: cfsheridan on February 05, 2009, 07:51:23 PM
Recently replaced the "P" panel with a "B" panel and added environment and bean mass temperature probes.

Pictures and write-up at the blog link below.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: YasBean on February 06, 2009, 08:18:56 AM
Recently replaced the "P" panel with a "B" panel and added environment and bean mass temperature probes.

Pictures and write-up at the blog link below.
Very cool!  I have the P, and sometimes wonder whether a B would not be better.  I have asked Michael at HotTop to set up a forum on their site so HT users can share their profiles for different beans.  The bean mass thermo seems to be very valuable, but why did you install another environmental thermo?  Is the installed thermo not accurate enough, or do you want the USB from your datalogger?
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: cfsheridan on February 06, 2009, 11:41:30 AM
Recently replaced the "P" panel with a "B" panel and added environment and bean mass temperature probes.

Pictures and write-up at the blog link below.
Very cool!  I have the P, and sometimes wonder whether a B would not be better.  I have asked Michael at HotTop to set up a forum on their site so HT users can share their profiles for different beans.  The bean mass thermo seems to be very valuable, but why did you install another environmental thermo?  Is the installed thermo not accurate enough, or do you want the USB from your datalogger?

The standard thermocouple is coupled too closely to the rear wall temperature, so it varies with outside air temperature and whether the roaster is cold or hot.  It tracks well with the profile, so it serves its purpose for the stock model, but it is not an accurate measure of the environmental temperature driving the beans.

I had a little trouble this morning--was getting some goofy things with the environmental probe--its temperature went lower than the bean temp with the heater on (and bean temperature rising after 1st crack was concluded).  I knew it was off.  Pulled the TC wire out from the tube a bit on both probes, and the next three roasts tracked perfectly.

Here's what makes having temperature and full control great:

First two roasts were intended to be FC/FC+ with a Triple-pick Sumatra.  Both went between 4-5 minutes from first crack start to end of roast, with end bean temp around 440.  Last roast was an Ethiopian Natural Sidamo, which I pulled at 420, but with the control and temperature monitoring, I still had over 4 minutes from start of first to end of roast, without stalling.

"Vincent!  We happy?"
"Yeah, we happy."

I'll have a few profiles posted later today.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: cfsheridan on February 06, 2009, 05:57:28 PM
I promised plots--here are two.

Full story is here (http://noquartercoffee.wordpress.com/).
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: shakin_jake on February 07, 2009, 03:14:16 PM
I have a question for you Hot Top Users...I have been roasting in a Behmor since last July full time (every bean I drink) and have 90 + roasts logged on it.  I'm wanting to try another roaster and the Hot Top looks like the one.  Here's my question/questions:

I roast inside my garage...it's 1000 square feet, I raise one of two overhead doors and a walkway door on an opposite wall to create cross ventilation (to deal with smoke)

The Behmor uses an afterburner to cut down on smoke.  The research I have been doing (reading about the Hot Top), indicates there is no smoke eater function on the Hot Top, is that right?

So the Hot Top is smokier than the Behmor.  Do any of you find that to be a problem?  What are you doing to control the smoke, if anything?  Where do you use your Hot Top?


Jake
Reddick Fla.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: MMW on February 07, 2009, 03:43:36 PM

So the Hot Top is smokier than the Behmor.

Cant' answer that as I don't have a Behmor-- I did, however, previously roast on a whirlypop for a while before I went the Hottop route.  There is noticeably less smoke on the Hottop than the whirlypop, if that helps at all.

Quote
  Do any of you find that to be a problem? 

Nope

Quote
What are you doing to control the smoke, if anything?  Where do you use your Hot Top?

I use mine on the stove top under the venthood.  When we remodeled our kitchen I put in the biggest, meanest venthood my wife would let me cram in.  1400 cfm will clear the kitchen pretty quick  ;D.  I've roasted 2 lbs in the last 24 hours (2 batches last night, 2 this morning) and can honestly say you can't tell in the house.  HTH.

-MMW
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: bibletec on February 07, 2009, 04:15:55 PM
Here's an opportunity for someone to get a deal http://cgi.ebay.com/Hottop-Home-Coffee-Roaster_W0QQitemZ140300059679QQcmdZViewItemQQptZSmall_Kitchen_Appliances_US?hash=item140300059679&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14&_trkparms=66%3A2|65%3A10|39%3A1|240%3A1318 (http://cgi.ebay.com/Hottop-Home-Coffee-Roaster_W0QQitemZ140300059679QQcmdZViewItemQQptZSmall_Kitchen_Appliances_US?hash=item140300059679&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14&_trkparms=66%3A2|65%3A10|39%3A1|240%3A1318)
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: milowebailey on February 07, 2009, 04:18:25 PM
Well I think I may be the newest Hottopper in the clu.  I pincked 1 up this am, for the Milowidget project....  I will have a few questions, so thanks in advance!!!
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: cfsheridan on February 07, 2009, 06:13:43 PM
I have a question for you Hot Top Users...I have been roasting in a Behmor since last July full time (every bean I drink) and have 90 + roasts logged on it.  I'm wanting to try another roaster and the Hot Top looks like the one.  Here's my question/questions:

I roast inside my garage...it's 1000 square feet, I raise one of two overhead doors and a walkway door on an opposite wall to create cross ventilation (to deal with smoke)

The Behmor uses an afterburner to cut down on smoke.  The research I have been doing (reading about the Hot Top), indicates there is no smoke eater function on the Hot Top, is that right?

So the Hot Top is smokier than the Behmor.  Do any of you find that to be a problem?  What are you doing to control the smoke, if anything?  Where do you use your Hot Top?


Jake
Reddick Fla.

I roast in a 2 car garage without any crossflow, and I don't keep the doors open all the time when roasting in winter.  You can tell that I roast coffee in there, but no one's complained yet.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: shakin_jake on February 07, 2009, 06:18:36 PM

So the Hot Top is smokier than the Behmor.

Cant' answer that as I don't have a Behmor-- I did, however, previously roast on a whirlypop for a while before I went the Hottop route.  There is noticeably less smoke on the Hottop than the whirlypop, if that helps at all.



Quote
  Do any of you find that to be a problem? 

Nope

Quote
What are you doing to control the smoke, if anything?  Where do you use your Hot Top?

I use mine on the stove top under the venthood.  When we remodeled our kitchen I put in the biggest, meanest venthood my wife would let me cram in.  1400 cfm will clear the kitchen pretty quick  ;D.  I've roasted 2 lbs in the last 24 hours (2 batches last night, 2 this morning) and can honestly say you can't tell in the house.  HTH.

-MMW




~~~~Thanks for the feedback.  The range hood in my kitchen although more powerful than the last house, will not suck the smoke the Behmor emits, so I roast in the garage, which I might add, is attached.  I roast against the wall that adjoins the house, so the fumes have to travel 20' to either open door

I should also mention the reason for my smoke concern is because, I'm asthmatic, hence my concern how much smoke the Hot Top puts out



Jake
Reddick Fla.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: shakin_jake on February 07, 2009, 07:11:11 PM

[/quote]

I roast in a 2 car garage without any crossflow, and I don't keep the doors open all the time when roasting in winter.  You can tell that I roast coffee in there, but no one's complained yet.
[/quote]


~~~Thanks for the feedback.  How long have you been using the Hot Top?



Jake
Reddick Fla.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: 4thJohn on February 07, 2009, 07:56:38 PM
Well I think I may be the newest Hottopper in the clu.  I pincked 1 up this am, for the Milowidget project....  I will have a few questions, so thanks in advance!!!
Larry,since you now have this new roaster...,if one of the twins needs a good home...Your friend,John
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: milowebailey on February 07, 2009, 08:03:19 PM
Well I think I may be the newest Hottopper in the clu.  I pincked 1 up this am, for the Milowidget project....  I will have a few questions, so thanks in advance!!!
Larry,since you now have this new roaster...,if one of the twins needs a good home...Your friend,John
the second of the twin never made it.... Tex kept it.  Otherwise, you'd be 1st in line.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: 4thJohn on February 07, 2009, 08:06:41 PM
Well I think I may be the newest Hottopper in the clu.  I pincked 1 up this am, for the Milowidget project....  I will have a few questions, so thanks in advance!!!
Larry,since you now have this new roaster...,if one of the twins needs a good home...Your friend,John
the second of the twin never made it.... Tex kept it.  Otherwise, you'd be 1st in line.
Okay :(
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: YasBean on February 07, 2009, 08:10:28 PM
We used to have a 600fpm hood under which I roasted, but since we moved, we have only a 300fpm microrange-hood with questionable installation.  The smoke doesn't bother me, though.  The smoke that does linger adds atmosphere to our new urban pad.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: shakin_jake on March 08, 2009, 10:15:04 PM
Thought I'd update this post.  I bought a Hot Top, have a dozen roasts on it so far.  What a beauty!  Smoke is not bad.  As I mentioned, I'm asthmatic so how much it smokes is a concern and I'm not having a problem with it

What I find I'm doing, once it hits 1st crack, I'll remove the bean chute cover and crank the fan up a tad.  The probe temp still goes up.  I'm trying to lengthen the time between 1st and 2nd crack.  Am I on the right track?

Been roasting with a DP Yirg (IMV), it's not very humid this time of year (so very un-Fla. like=:-) so I think that makes the roast quick at the end but all in all, bean/roast quality is high using this roaster


Jake
Reddick Fla.
Whatever hits the fan will not be distributed equally...
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: cfsheridan on March 09, 2009, 03:11:09 AM
Sounds like you have the "B" model.

To lengthen the time between 1st and 2nd, you want to lower the heater power BEFORE 1st starts (I usually try to do this at least a minute before 1st starts) to around 50-60%.  That should give you a slow trip through 1st crack, and help get your total time between the start of 1st to end of roast to about 4 minutes.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: shakin_jake on March 09, 2009, 10:17:17 AM
That makes sense, cutting the power to the heater back rather than venting the heat.  Thanks for the tip Chad


Jake
Reddick Fla.
Whatever hits the fan will not be evenly distributed...
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: shakin_jake on March 09, 2009, 03:49:45 PM
Chad,  I forgot to mention...Yes, I bought the B model



Jake
Reddick Fla.
Whatever hits the fan will not be evenly distributed
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: shakin_jake on March 12, 2009, 11:42:34 PM
Chad,  I tried what you suggested, lowering the heater to 50-60% a minute before 1st crack started.  It allowed the roast sit in the drum about 50 more seconds.  Very nice!


Jake
Reddick Fla.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: milowebailey on March 27, 2009, 07:07:35 AM
Does anyone know what the "filter material" is for the top filter on the Hottop?

I ordered a rear filter when I got my used hottop but didn't notice then that the top filter is shot...

I know Hottop sells the complete filter, but is seems you should just be able to replace the filter material.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: Dante on March 27, 2009, 07:31:44 AM
Does anyone know what the "filter material" is for the top filter on the Hottop?

I ordered a rear filter when I got my used hottop but didn't notice then that the top filter is shot...

I know Hottop sells the complete filter, but is seems you should just be able to replace the filter material.

I asked this same question sometime back but got no answer Larry. I tried using the filter material used for range hoods but the heat in the Hottop is much too intense for that. If you find the right replacement material, and need to buy more of it than you need, I 'll be happy to split the cost and the material with you.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: cfsheridan on March 27, 2009, 08:49:04 AM
Does anyone know what the "filter material" is for the top filter on the Hottop?

I ordered a rear filter when I got my used hottop but didn't notice then that the top filter is shot...

I know Hottop sells the complete filter, but is seems you should just be able to replace the filter material.

I asked this same question sometime back but got no answer Larry. I tried using the filter material used for range hoods but the heat in the Hottop is much too intense for that. If you find the right replacement material, and need to buy more of it than you need, I 'll be happy to split the cost and the material with you.

Is it worth the trip?  The replacement is $10 (including the metal), and I just keep two and soak the assembly in a cafiza wash every hundred roasts or so.  Dante--may be worth it for you given shipping costs, but for US, I don't see why it's needed.  My $0.02.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: milowebailey on March 27, 2009, 12:20:58 PM


Is it worth the trip?  The replacement is $10 (including the metal), and I just keep two and soak the assembly in a cafiza wash every hundred roasts or so.  Dante--may be worth it for you given shipping costs, but for US, I don't see why it's needed.  My $0.02.
Just the engineer in me....
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: cfsheridan on March 27, 2009, 12:23:24 PM


Is it worth the trip?  The replacement is $10 (including the metal), and I just keep two and soak the assembly in a cafiza wash every hundred roasts or so.  Dante--may be worth it for you given shipping costs, but for US, I don't see why it's needed.  My $0.02.
Just the engineer in me....

I've kept my professional registration, but been doing too much project management, clearly.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: slurp on March 29, 2009, 10:33:53 AM
Recently replaced the "P" panel with a "B" panel and added environment and bean mass temperature probes.

Pictures and write-up at the blog link below.

I'm a new user with the "B" panel. Question: Why would an experienced roaster like yourself want to switch from the more sophisticated "P" panel in favor of a "B" panel?

With my "B", I have been struggling to do profile modifications from "Auto" mode but finding everything goes so fast! It has seemed to me that maybe I should have bought the "P" model so that I could program a profile ahead of time.

I went to your blog but couldn't find any text there that answered my questions above.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: shakin_jake on March 29, 2009, 10:50:34 AM
Slurp,  Chad will forget more about the Hot Top than I know.  I only have 20 roasts on mine

Having said that, the first 17 cycles I was roasting a dry processed (DP) Yirg (IMV) that went quick through the cycle.  I found by taking Chad's  advice of lowering the heater output to 50 or 60% of it's capacity one minute before 1st crack, I got a longer roast out of it.  Pull the bean chute cover at the same time and the roast will extend even longer

Now the last 3 roasts I ran through the Hot Top have been a Sumatran, must be a wet process bean as there is little if any chaff, but the bean is much larger and has to be harder than the Yirg as the roast time is way longer to get up to a FC +


FWIW, I'm pretty impressed with the Hot Top.  Before that, I ran all my roasts through a Behmor.  96 Behmor roasts to be exact.  The Hot Top allows more control over the roast compared to the Behmor.  I have the Hot top B model and at this point, no desire to want to use the P panel



Jake
Reddick Fla.
History teaches us that we learn little from history...
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: cfsheridan on March 29, 2009, 12:55:45 PM
Recently replaced the "P" panel with a "B" panel and added environment and bean mass temperature probes.

Pictures and write-up at the blog link below.

I'm a new user with the "B" panel. Question: Why would an experienced roaster like yourself want to switch from the more sophisticated "P" panel in favor of a "B" panel?

With my "B", I have been struggling to do profile modifications from "Auto" mode but finding everything goes so fast! It has seemed to me that maybe I should have bought the "P" model so that I could program a profile ahead of time.

I went to your blog but couldn't find any text there that answered my questions above.

Simple:  The "P" does not allow direct manual control of the heater and the fan during the roast.  The "B" does.  With the bean and environment probes, and knowledge of what bean I am roasting and what profile I'd like to achieve, I have total control over the roast.  The only real tricky part is having a sense for the time delay between dropping or increasing the heater power level and seeing the heat-up rate drop or rise (due to the thermal mass in the heating element).  Programming a profile ahead of time with the "P" assumes you can nail down what's needed in specific time increments.  With the "B", you can save a successful profile, and it will repeat itself with little to no adjustment.

For example, I ran three samples from the same region through it last week, intending to run the same profile.  I saved my first run, and then did not have to make many adjustments for the next two runs.  My intended profile was a City+ roast, with extra drying (these were relatively moist beans) with an extended time running between 350-370?F for extra caramelizing.  I noticed that the beans were moist during the first roast, so I lowered the heat and extended the drying time before 300?F while bumping up the fan speed to remove the moisture.

I have a general sense of where I want to go with each roast--the "B" allows me full control of the input parameters directly (heater power and fan speed).  The other thing I don't like about the "P" is that the heater is either on or off--there's no reduced power, so trying to ease things for longer drying periods or for lower grown/decaf beans is done by lowering the set temperatures, which means you're running full heater to the target temperature, and then nothing.  That does not make for an even ramp.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: Dante on March 29, 2009, 04:55:53 PM
I have been using the B for over a year now and I, too, prefer it to a fully "automated" roaster like the Sonofresco. I have greater control over the roast, with heat and fan control on the fly. With the B, I am able to follow the not so common roasting advice for beans like the Elida Natural which shines with a longer ramp up time to first crack. I can also extend the period between first and second crack depending on the suggested roast profile or the bean. Of course I have to stay with the machine throughout the roast process, but that is more than half the fun of it!
Title: Re: Hottop "B" over the "P"
Post by: slurp on March 30, 2009, 10:36:55 AM
Many thanks to CFSheridan and the two other posters for their comments. That perfectly answers my question -- and it erases all "post-decision regret" that I didn't buy the "P"!

This would seem to be one of those infrequent situations where a less expensive purchase trumps a more expensive one.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: YasBean on March 31, 2009, 07:11:47 PM
Ehh, I'm not so sure.  I, too, thought a "B" would be good, but got the "P" anyhow.  (I liked the look of the control panel.)  There have been times where I would really like to change things on the fly, but have found that the forced forethought has really paid off.  As I buy in 10-15# lots, I do get quite a few roasts from one bean, and it takes only a few to nail down the right profile.  I have settled on three or four main categories of profiles (wet processed, dry, high altitude, dark roast).  I actually enjoy setting a profile and then forcing myself to just "go along for the ride."  I occassional meddle with the temp setting or final timing, but usually regret it.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: cfsheridan on March 31, 2009, 07:52:36 PM
Ehh, I'm not so sure.  I, too, thought a "B" would be good, but got the "P" anyhow.  (I liked the look of the control panel.)  There have been times where I would really like to change things on the fly, but have found that the forced forethought has really paid off.  As I buy in 10-15# lots, I do get quite a few roasts from one bean, and it takes only a few to nail down the right profile.  I have settled on three or four main categories of profiles (wet processed, dry, high altitude, dark roast).  I actually enjoy setting a profile and then forcing myself to just "go along for the ride."  I occassional meddle with the temp setting or final timing, but usually regret it.

I understand your position.  I roasted at least 150# with the P control panel.  Here's my dealbreaker on the P--the profiles it runs have the heater running at either 100% or 0%.  That is insufficient control in a drum roaster for my uses, or will require me to babysit the roaster to coax 4 minutes or from first to 2nd or, when I'm roasting light, to pull 3-1/2 to 4 minutes from the start of first to the end of roast, not getting anywhere near 2nd crack.  Having watched over 100 roasts with two thermocouples and the B control panel, there's just no comparison, for me.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: slurp on April 01, 2009, 07:31:22 AM
It sounds like Hottop needs to combine the best features of the "B" and "P" on its next version of the control panel, namely,

1) the ahead-of-time profiling feature of the "P",

2) variable temperature control for the heater, as in the "B", rather than all (100%) or none (0%), as in the "P",

3) on-the-fly manual adjustments as in the "B".

It would be especially nice if that could be done as an optional panel upgrade for users of the present "B" and "P" roasters -- rather than requiring purchase of a new machine.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: YasBean on April 01, 2009, 09:33:14 AM
Yes, I do agree that the all-or-nothing is a pain, but with the seven stages, I just use short stages to "pulse" the heat.  I have noticed on this latest control panel (see  my meltdown (http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=5670.0) for why I have a new control panel) that the heat is controlled in Celcius, and so the power cuts off a degree or two before what I set it to in Fahrenheit.  It's enough to make a guy want to be bold and go over to the metric side! ;)
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: J.Jirehs Roaster on April 01, 2009, 11:19:45 AM
It sounds like Hottop needs to combine the best features of the "B" and "P" on its next version of the control panel, namely,

1) the ahead-of-time profiling feature of the "P",

2) variable temperature control for the heater, as in the "B", rather than all (100%) or none (0%), as in the "P",

3) on-the-fly manual adjustments as in the "B".

It would be especially nice if that could be done as an optional panel upgrade for users of the present "B" and "P" roasters -- rather than requiring purchase of a new machine.


Milowbailey is working on it  ;D

Link is here (http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=5382.0)
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: alongfortheride on May 24, 2009, 02:26:23 PM
Got my new (to me) hot top B coming this week - got on Ebay for $550 shipped, unit looks barely used.  :)
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: shakin_jake on May 25, 2009, 09:26:10 PM
I'm likin' my 'B' model Hot Top.  Had it now for 3 months*, did roast #60 with it the other day.  What I like about this roaster...it's ready to roll with right out of the box.  No learning curve to get a good roast right from the beginning.  The dump feature to get the beans into the cooling tray right out of the roaster 'like now' is pretty awesome.  Push dump and they're cooling, no more heat


Jake
Reddick Fla.

*Time to pull the back off the roaster and dust it out some (according to the user manual)
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: Dante on May 26, 2009, 12:29:03 AM
You said it, Jake! I have a Sonofresco also but the Hottop B gets the most mileage in my home. I use it especially for the high end beans that we get here on GCBC - the JBM, IMV, Gesha, and Konas all get roasted on the Hottop only. Haven't pooched a roast on it yet!
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: krus on May 30, 2009, 09:05:14 AM
Does anyone know how much influence the distance from element to drum makes? Ive had my Hottop for just over 1 year and noticed the element was a bit warped and it was slightly resting on the inside of the metal housing so I decided it might be time to replace it even though it seemed to be heating the beans ok. As I was installing the new one, I found that I had to bend the feet slightly in order to get it positioned correctly and not contact the drum as it rotates. It's position is definitely closer to the drum than before but I didn't think too much of it. My first roast with the new element was quite a bit faster than before and following my previous profile, 1C and 2C ran together. I'm not sure if it's due to the element being new or the position of it that is the factor. Looks like I'm going to have to adjust my roast profile or batch size with the new element. What do you think? Thanks

- Matt
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: shakin_jake on May 30, 2009, 09:11:55 AM
crimpo (Chas rimpo), a member here has replaced his Hot Top's heater element before.  I'm sure he would have some worthy input for you 


Jake
Reddick Fla.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: Stubbie on May 30, 2009, 01:04:42 PM
Does anyone know how much influence the distance from element to drum makes? Ive had my Hottop for just over 1 year and noticed the element was a bit warped and it was slightly resting on the inside of the metal housing so I decided it might be time to replace it even though it seemed to be heating the beans ok. As I was installing the new one, I found that I had to bend the feet slightly in order to get it positioned correctly and not contact the drum as it rotates. It's position is definitely closer to the drum than before but I didn't think too much of it. My first roast with the new element was quite a bit faster than before and following my previous profile, 1C and 2C ran together. I'm not sure if it's due to the element being new or the position of it that is the factor. Looks like I'm going to have to adjust my roast profile or batch size with the new element. What do you think? Thanks

- Matt

I think you are exactly right.  The new element will burn hotter than the element with many hours on it, and it's proximity to the drum will also speed things up.

We're always tweaking profiles to get the best out of the bean, I bet you get this one figured out pretty quick!

-Stubbie
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: Dante on May 30, 2009, 05:04:51 PM
I replaced my heating element a couple of months ago and noticed slightly shorter roast times on my usal profiles so I had to adjust for that. This happens when I replace the filters also. That's why I love the B so much. I can pretty much tweak my roast on the fly.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: alongfortheride on June 02, 2009, 06:21:25 AM
Any advice on working with the 'D' model?  Looks like time is the only parameter I can adjust.  Sipping my first roast of Brazil Moreninha at 17:30 and it's light years ahead of anything I've done by heat gun or the Fresh Roast.  Only resting about 12 hours, too.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Steve7 on June 16, 2009, 03:14:23 PM
Noticed the display gives temp if Farenheit.

Does it switch to centigrade too??? (particularly UK models).

I would hate to be stuck without modern measures!!
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on June 16, 2009, 09:08:49 PM
Steve,  It all depends on which model you have how to change between fahrenheit or celcius.  With the B model unplugged you hold the select button in (depress), plug the unit in and hold the select button for 3 seconds.  the machine then gives an audible double beep.  When you hear the beep, release that button

Now use the chevron up or down to change back and forth between C or F.  When you have display temp you want to use, press the eject button

If you have a different model, go to their online site and choose the model you have and download the user manual.  That info will be in there


Jake
Reddick Fla.
"It's never too late to have a happy childhood"
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Steve7 on June 17, 2009, 02:51:59 AM
Thanks, mine hasn't been ordered yet, but I wanted to check before I bought it.
Good news, thanks.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: 4thJohn on June 24, 2009, 01:28:47 PM
what is the roast capacity for the hottop?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on June 24, 2009, 01:36:16 PM
~ 1/2 lb capacity
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Steve7 on July 22, 2009, 02:13:30 PM
How do you guys create the plots, and the graphs?
Particular software?

I have the B version, and just use the auto function and eject as I hear 2nd crack. Total amateur.

I would like to start plotting some charts to help me learn.

Any advice appreciated (just got the machine temp... will not be fitting a probe).


As an aside, its a damn nuisance that centigrade isn't the common standard!
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on July 22, 2009, 09:02:35 PM
I have the B version, and just use the auto function and eject as I hear 2nd crack. Total amateur.

~~~Ignorance is bliss isn't it?=:-)


As an aside, its a damn nuisance that centigrade isn't the common standard!


~~~It's easy to change from fahrenheit to celsius.  Go back into this thread and you'll see where I have described the process

By the by, I too use this machine as the factory intended.  Sometimes I'll slow it down, stretching the time between 1st and 2nd crack by dropping the heat a minute before it hits 1st crack but that's about it for me modding my profiles, and I'm getting what I consider good roast results.  And like you, I let the roast hit the front of 2nd crack then stop it.  I may be drinking more of a roast profile but i find the espresso extraction is better hitting 2nd crack, and espresso is what I drink   


Jake
Reddick Fla.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: psedillo on August 01, 2009, 02:11:20 PM
Over the past month my Hottop has trouble releasing the beans, it appears that something is causing the door to stick and not open properly. Is this a common problem and is there an easy fix?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on August 01, 2009, 02:33:26 PM
Over the past month my Hottop has trouble releasing the beans, it appears that something is causing the door to stick and not open properly. Is this a common problem and is there an easy fix?
Clean it....you may have to take part of it apart to get in there, but if the hinge for the flap gets full of goo then it will stick and not open well.  If that's not it, then the solenoid is going out.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on August 01, 2009, 04:46:41 PM
I'd suggest emailing Michael Chang (Hot Top USA in NY) about your trouble.  He may have a good answer and suggestion.  All the times I have taken the drum out of my Hot Top roaster to clean the roaster chamber, I never noticed the door being particularly covered in roasting soot, but I did clean all of the surfaces inside the roaster thorough as possible using a sloution of Joe Glo espresso machine cleaner (high grade of TSP) and warm water/3M pad/sponge.  FWIW, I have had no problems with the door opening and closing when it should.  As far as that goes, I have had no problems with this roaster and just did roast # 94 with it yesterday. 


Jake
Reddick Fla.
The very purpose of existence is to reconcile the glowing opinion we have of ourselves with the appalling things that other people think about us.
-- Quentin Crisp
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: cfsheridan on August 01, 2009, 05:07:29 PM
[snip]...As far as that goes, I have had no problems with this roaster and just did roast # 94 with it yesterday. 


That's not even broken in yet.  :P
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: psedillo on August 02, 2009, 07:06:58 AM
Thank you all for the replies, I'll break it down today and clean it. Sounds like this might fix the problem.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on August 02, 2009, 09:23:44 AM
There is an upgraded solenoid hinge for the door that replaced the original within about the last year I believe.  My original HT-B had a defective one that went out and worked intermittently.  Michael replaced it under warranty immediately.  The key to seeing if it is stuck is to take a chopstick with the front cover off and gently push the door open.  If you can't ALWAYS open the door that way you have a problem and it need replacement.  Of course it can't hurt to give it a good cleaning first and check it again but I can't see how it can get shut tight enough to prevent pushing it open.

Good luck and I'm certain Michael will make it right.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: staylor on August 02, 2009, 10:54:24 AM
I stopped counting how many roasts I've done on the HT somewhere around the 400th. If I was to guess I'd think maybe 600 roasts???

I've never had the sticking door problem but I take mine completely apart on occasion and get rid of any lodged in chaff and also de-gunk the stickier parts. Mine has been an absolute workhorse and I expect it to continue doing it's thing for some time.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Steve7 on August 02, 2009, 12:02:54 PM
I think I have done 5?

I feel so young.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: staylor on August 02, 2009, 12:21:29 PM
Newbie. ;-)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on August 02, 2009, 02:00:34 PM
I stopped counting how many roasts I've done on the HT somewhere around the 400th. If I was to guess I'd think maybe 600 roasts???


~~~600 roasts, that's impressive!  What have you needed to replace during this time to keep it running besides the requisite filter replacement?

Anyone log more than 600 roasts?  If so, what's your part failure total, and when (after how many roasts if you logged it)?  I'm going to assume there are some items that will eventually fail like the heating element, motor, etc.  I'm just curious what others have had to do to keep their Hot Top running



Jake
Reddick Fla.
The power of accurate observation is commonly called cynicism by those who
have not got it.
- - George Bernard Shaw

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: staylor on August 02, 2009, 02:23:17 PM
I replaced the heating element on the advice of Michael at Hottop USA, as the roast time was starting to slow down. I don't replace my filters too often, I clean them in Cafiza and it seems to work like a charm.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Mlee on August 08, 2009, 08:30:49 AM
I stopped counting how many roasts I've done on the HT somewhere around the 400th. If I was to guess I'd think maybe 600 roasts???


~~~600 roasts, that's impressive!  What have you needed to replace during this time to keep it running besides the requisite filter replacement?

Anyone log more than 600 roasts?  If so, what's your part failure total, and when (after how many roasts if you logged it)?  I'm going to assume there are some items that will eventually fail like the heating element, motor, etc.  I'm just curious what others have had to do to keep their Hot Top running



Jake
Reddick Fla.
The power of accurate observation is commonly called cynicism by those who
have not got it.
- - George Bernard Shaw



I am coming up on 1,000 roasts on my Hottop. I have been thru one heating element, two fusible links.(I have eliminated that and looped the connection) One drum had a faulty weld that Michael from Hottop replaced under warranty. Other than that this thing keeps humming along. I attribute the heating element and the fusible links to my rapid cooling of it by running a fan into the chamber to cool it off. I have a brand new Hottop in the garage if this one ever poos out....
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: UnConundrum on October 16, 2009, 06:19:40 PM
I bought mine in 2004.  I don't log anything, but I must do at least 150 roasts a year, so that puts me over 600 I guess.  I still have an 8828, no letters, just 8828.  Only thing I've replaced is the control panel which, after about a year, was very, very hard to push the buttons.  A new board was sent to me at no charge.  Although my heating element is warped, I've not replaced anything else.  That's saying a lot as we're very bad at maintenance.  My wife usually roasts the coffee and does no maintenance.  I cleaned it tonight, the chaff tray was sticking out about a half inch due to the accumulation.  We're very poor at replacing the filters....  I'd say it's quite the accolade for their product.  
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on October 23, 2009, 05:50:56 PM
I have a question regarding using a hottop to profile (or get close) to what my Ambex will do.

I've been thinking about the roast profile time.

The hottop takes 20 - 24 minutes for a roast.

Typically I roast on the Ambex 12 - 15 minutes.

Is there a relationship between the two that I should consider? 
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: cfsheridan on October 23, 2009, 05:58:13 PM
I have a question regarding using a hottop to profile (or get close) to what my Ambex will do.

I've been thinking about the roast profile time.

The hottop takes 20 - 24 minutes for a roast.

Typically I roast on the Ambex 12 - 15 minutes.

Is there a relationship between the two that I should consider? 

Drop the batch size and up the preheat on the hottop.  Stay ~200-230g, and get the stock backwall thermocouple to ~250-265.  Roasts should then be in the 14-15 min range.  Proliles on my hottop are comparable (even more so with less batch size) to a YM-2.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on October 23, 2009, 09:36:53 PM
I have a question regarding using a hottop to profile (or get close) to what my Ambex will do.

I've been thinking about the roast profile time.

The hottop takes 20 - 24 minutes for a roast.

Typically I roast on the Ambex 12 - 15 minutes.

Is there a relationship between the two that I should consider? 




~~~~Milow,  FWIW, I'm roasting exclusively on a newer Hot Top B model.  It takes me approx. 14 mintues to get 250 grams of green beans into 2nd crack then dumping the roast to cool

More often than not, I add my 250 grams of beans as soon as the pre-heat cycle ends, so there is approx. 18 minutes on the countdown timer and 165 degrees F showing on the Hot Top's digital display.  Looking at my roast log, most roasts are finished with about 4 minutes left on the display



Jake
Reddick Fla.
If he's got golf clubs in his truck or a camper in his driveway, I don't hire him.
--Lou Holtz, football coach
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on October 23, 2009, 09:58:17 PM
Hmmm, maybe my heating element needs to be replaced.  Most of the time with 250 grams I barely get to half way into 1st crack at 18 minutes.. have to push add time and normally hit 2nd right at the buzzer (30 seconds left)...  Now with the milowidget I have way more control and can get it done in about 17 minutes.  

Mine is the old digital model.. and I've been using the factory controller because I want to replace the thermocouples with better ones for the milowidget version.. haven't gotten around to it....  and brought the Hottop up to the cabin for weekend sample roasting.

Maybe it's time to finish that project up.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Steve7 on October 24, 2009, 02:15:49 AM
Like shakin Jake, I conclude my roasting business anywhere from 6 to about 4 mins left on my timer (adding at 18mins).

Buy a new element and keep under 250g to get the best out of the batch.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: staylor on October 24, 2009, 06:56:45 AM
Yup, new heating element.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: cfsheridan on October 24, 2009, 07:31:30 AM
Yup, new heating element.

+1

You should be to 1st well before 18m with 250g.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on October 24, 2009, 05:48:06 PM
I am usually just skimming the margins of 2c by 16:30 mins on my 2 year old P model. 250g added at the beginning of the "add beans" beeps.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on October 24, 2009, 06:53:34 PM
I know this has been discussed before but I just wanted to mention to Milow, since he didn't say how many volts he has at this outlet when roasting (just that he thinks his heater element is suspect)...Ideally, you want 120 volts when the roaster heater is at full ouput

This is easy to check with a multimeter that has an AC volt meter (most do).  Most plug ins (electrical outlets) have two receptacles, so your roaster is plugged into one, probe the other with your AC voltmeter 



Jake
Reddick Fla.
It is inexcusable for scientists to torture animals; let them make their experiments on journalists and politicians.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on October 24, 2009, 07:10:29 PM
I've been getting my best results lately using 225 gm batches.

I set the time to max (25 minutes) on the profile and dump/add the beans at 23 minutes (two minutes after the auto profile).  The temp generally reads about 265* or so.  I immediately lower the heat to 80% to dry at a bit lower heat levels.  At 325* I run the fan at 75% for 30 seconds and then lower to 25% for the rest of the roast.  At the same time I increase the heat to 100% until about 380* or so when I lower the heat to 70% until start of first crack which is usually about 12 minutes after I dump the beans (11 minutes left on the clock).  As first get strong I lower heat again to about 50% to extend first crack and the time to second.  I then dump the beans to cool at the desired roast level.  Sometimes I will increase heat to get to second crack at the desired time of about 4 minutes after the start of first crack.

Works for me.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on October 24, 2009, 07:12:43 PM
I emailed Hottop USA today and after a volley of emails they suggest replacing the heating element and temperature sensor.  I guess I'll order those tomorrow.

Anyone ever changed the heating element?  Any tips?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: staylor on October 24, 2009, 10:25:13 PM
I emailed Hottop USA today and after a volley of emails they suggest replacing the heating element and temperature sensor.  I guess I'll order those tomorrow.

Anyone ever changed the heating element?  Any tips?

It's easy, I've done it once before. I think there is a link floating around on Hottop's website somewhere.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Mlee on October 28, 2009, 12:30:53 PM
I emailed Hottop USA today and after a volley of emails they suggest replacing the heating element and temperature sensor.  I guess I'll order those tomorrow.

Anyone ever changed the heating element?  Any tips?

It's easy, I've done it once before. I think there is a link floating around on Hottop's website somewhere.
[/quot

Once you take the back panel off its just to screws holding it in place
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on October 28, 2009, 02:00:19 PM
The parts should be here today.  Hottop sent me a link to the instructions.

thanks for the help!!

Milowebailey
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: George Coury on October 28, 2009, 03:08:51 PM
I've had a programmable hottop for almost 2 years now which I bought directly from them. I have had to replace several items. I am only roasting for myself so it is not getting anything but light use. Now my LCD screen is going bad and half the information is unreadable. I note Larry's issues with the heating element on his older machine. Those of you with hottops, have you been happy with the reliability? I am becoming increasingly disappointed with it's electronics. I am wondering if this is par for this machine or have I got a lemon?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: cfsheridan on October 28, 2009, 03:30:38 PM
Sounds like you have a lemon.  I've used and abused my hottop, and haven't had any trouble.  Done up to 22 roasts in a day, no problem.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: staylor on October 28, 2009, 04:30:18 PM
I've had a programmable hottop for almost 2 years now which I bought directly from them. I have had to replace several items. I am only roasting for myself so it is not getting anything but light use. Now my LCD screen is going bad and half the information is unreadable. I note Larry's issues with the heating element on his older machine. Those of you with hottops, have you been happy with the reliability? I am becoming increasingly disappointed with it's electronics. I am wondering if this is par for this machine or have I got a lemon?

I've done hundreds of roasts on mine, anything that I've had to replace (heating element) is what I consider reasonable wear and tear. I'm completely happy with mine.

I'd recommend dropping an email to Michael at Hottop and asking him his thoughts, they have a pretty good reputation.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on October 28, 2009, 06:41:36 PM
I've had a programmable hottop for almost 2 years now which I bought directly from them. I have had to replace several items. I am only roasting for myself so it is not getting anything but light use. Now my LCD screen is going bad and half the information is unreadable. I note Larry's issues with the heating element on his older machine. Those of you with hottops, have you been happy with the reliability? I am becoming increasingly disappointed with it's electronics. I am wondering if this is par for this machine or have I got a lemon?
I agree that you must have a lemon.  My experience with repairing a HotTop resulted from when I melted my own P model base (http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=5670.0), resulting in my having to replace the body and panel.  It was easy and fun.  Everything you need to know is on the HotTop website.  I would suggest, though, that you take a photograph of the wire connections on the p.c. board before disconnecting the panel.  There were a few wires that were not obvious to me, and the numbered labels fell off, so I had to reconnect through analysis and trial and error.  No harm done, in the end.  Hundreds of roasts before the repair, and a hundred or so since.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Steve7 on October 29, 2009, 03:03:15 AM
(http://crystalcraven.files.wordpress.com/2009/07/lemon.jpg)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: George Coury on October 30, 2009, 10:13:07 AM
([url]http://crystalcraven.files.wordpress.com/2009/07/lemon.jpg[/url])

I don't understand what you're implying sir? LOL!
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on October 31, 2009, 01:58:49 PM
Replaced my heating element today.... that was the problem.  The new heating element was a pain because when I installed it the end toward the viewing window rubbed the drum.  I had to install a shim under the mounting bracket.  Once I did that it no longer rubbed.  I also installed new thermocouples for the Milowidget.  I had bought some better screw-in type thermocouples to get better readings. 

I am now able to get to 2nd crack in under 16 minutes with 200 grams...
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Steve7 on October 31, 2009, 03:50:56 PM
The lemon bites back.

(http://www.fotosearch.com/bthumb/CSP/CSP187/k1875849.jpg)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: George Coury on December 12, 2009, 10:27:04 AM
Just a followup:
I got a chance to talk ( Via email) to Michael about my problem Hottop and he has sent me some parts to replace on my Hottop. He was easy to deal with, and I cannot say his service has ever been a problem. I will be replacing those parts this weekend and just hope for regular maintenance issues down the road. I appreciate everyone's input on this.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on January 12, 2010, 07:37:50 AM
I thought I had my HT-P all set up, with good profiles for different beans and roasts, but after I bought a batch of Kona from Lion's Gate, I was very disappointed.  After several roasts on my "Kona" profile (slow ramp with a long dehydration around 350F), which BTW works just fine with Purple Mountain and Thunder Mountain, I thought the Lion's Gate was flat and uninteresting.  A week ago, I thought, what the heck, I might as well try it with my slightly modified Standard profile and run it into espresso roast.  This stuff is REALLY GOOD!!!
So, my dilemma is, I think I no longer know ANYTHING about profiling or roasting!  For one thing, programming the HT-P is quite abstract, as the temps one sets are just a general method of turning the heating element on and off, but say nothing about where the roast will be at any point in time.  Then, if by chance, I find a profile that seems to bring out the special notes of a bean, which is looking more and more hit-and-miss, I no longer have any idea of how to tweak the profile to make it better.
What methods are others with HT-Ps using to create and modify profiles?  Should I bother trying to "theorize" about where to stretch the ramp and where to push it, other than after 1st crack, of course?  Or am I just thinking too much, and should just use the stinkin' modified Standard for Lion's Gate, and whatever I have programmed for whatever else I want to roast, because no matter what, it will be a heck of a lot better than if I were using an air popper?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: garybt3 on January 12, 2010, 07:50:45 AM
I thought I had my HT-P all set up, with good profiles for different beans and roasts, but after I bought a batch of Kona from Lion's Gate, I was very disappointed.  After several roasts on my "Kona" profile (slow ramp with a long dehydration around 350F), which BTW works just fine with Purple Mountain and Thunder Mountain, I thought the Lion's Gate was flat and uninteresting.  A week ago, I thought, what the heck, I might as well try it with my slightly modified Standard profile and run it into espresso roast.  This stuff is REALLY GOOD!!!
So, my dilemma is, I think I no longer know ANYTHING about profiling or roasting!  For one thing, programming the HT-P is quite abstract, as the temps one sets are just a general method of turning the heating element on and off, but say nothing about where the roast will be at any point in time.  Then, if by chance, I find a profile that seems to bring out the special notes of a bean, which is looking more and more hit-and-miss, I no longer have any idea of how to tweak the profile to make it better.
What methods are others with HT-Ps using to create and modify profiles?  Should I bother trying to "theorize" about where to stretch the ramp and where to push it, other than after 1st crack, of course?  Or am I just thinking too much, and should just use the stinkin' modified Standard for Lion's Gate, and whatever I have programmed for whatever else I want to roast, because no matter what, it will be a heck of a lot better than if I were using an air popper?

I parked my Hottop P on the shelf, waiting for the day that the Milo widget is available...

I went back to my Tweaked out Poppery 1, Full Control over heat & airflow(also boosted the fan voltage) and up to 1/2 # batches.... I've roasted more than 200#'s in it & she just keeps on going...

I am working on my BBQ roaster, I just picked up a tread machine last weekend and stripped it down...the motor is 2HP and speed controlled. I am working out the gear drives, trying to separate the motor from the heat source. Thinking of using bicycle gears & chain, because there are 2 bikes in my toolshed taking up space  ;D
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on January 12, 2010, 08:51:10 AM

[/quote]

I parked my Hottop P on the shelf, waiting for the day that the Milo widget is available...

I went back to my Tweaked out Poppery 1, Full Control over heat & airflow(also boosted the fan voltage) and up to 1/2 # batches.... I've roasted more than 200#'s in it & she just keeps on going...

I am working on my BBQ roaster, I just picked up a tread machine last weekend and stripped it down...the motor is 2HP and speed controlled. I am working out the gear drives, trying to separate the motor from the heat source. Thinking of using bicycle gears & chain, because there are 2 bikes in my toolshed taking up space  ;D
[/quote]



~~~Gary,  You would be better off cleaning, lubing, adjusting the drivetrain on your bicycle and put some air in the tires so you could take it for a lengthy ride, just to get the endorphins in your bloodstream flowing...which would clear your mind so you could see your way to removing the P panel from your Hot Top and installing the B *upgrade*




Jake
Reddick Fla.
"The difference between genius and stupidity is that genius has it's limits"
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: garybt3 on January 12, 2010, 09:11:51 AM
There are 2 bikes & I can only ride 1 of them at a time!

I've been needing a 2 to 5 # roaster for some time.

A really bad windstorm destroyed my last BBQ drum setup...picked it up and tossed it like a leaf . This one is going to be Heavy Duty, mobile & able to take a punch ;-)

The Hottop is nice enough, but I'm sure I'd kill it if I kept using it to roast 5#'s a day X 3 day weekend...I have 4 spare Poppery 1's as backup machines, but the controls were made by a guy that dropped off my radar screen 2 years ago...Fantastic controller. I have the plans, just need need an electronics guy to build me a few of them... :-\

At the moment, I still need a BBQ roaster more than a 'B' panel for the Hottop.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: MMW on January 12, 2010, 09:26:50 AM
There are 2 bikes & I can only ride 1 of them at a time!

I've been needing a 2 to 5 # roaster for some time.

A really bad windstorm destroyed my last BBQ drum setup...picked it up and tossed it like a leaf . This one is going to be Heavy Duty, mobile & able to take a punch ;-)

The Hottop is nice enough, but I'm sure I'd kill it if I kept using it to roast 5#'s a day X 3 day weekend...I have 4 spare Poppery 1's as backup machines, but the controls were made by a guy that dropped off my radar screen 2 years ago...Fantastic controller. I have the plans, just need need an electronics guy to build me a few of them... :-\

At the moment, I still need a BBQ roaster more than a 'B' panel for the Hottop.


If you're roasting 15lbs per week I think you're probably out of Hottop range anyways. (except for small batches and test roasts, I guess).

3 batches (~1.5 lbs) a week at my current burn rate is about as much time as I really want to spend in front of the Hottop.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on January 12, 2010, 09:55:18 AM
3 batches (~1.5 lbs) a week at my current burn rate is about as much time as I really want to spend in front of the Hottop.
Well, if the profiles are good, you would really only need to spend a few minutes per batch in front of your Hottop.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: MMW on January 12, 2010, 10:10:09 AM
3 batches (~1.5 lbs) a week at my current burn rate is about as much time as I really want to spend in front of the Hottop.
Well, if the profiles are good, you would really only need to spend a few minutes per batch in front of your Hottop.

But placard on the side says "Do not leave roaster unattended while roasting"!  ::)

B panel...I'd need more than 3 profiles.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: garybt3 on January 12, 2010, 11:31:25 AM
The thing about the Hottop P is that you believe you have a great profile on 1 bean all worked out...and then it isn't really consistent on the next batch or 2.

You have to stay camped out in front of it, or risk the batch going wherever it feels like. Sort of.

It is good as a single home roaster, by that I mean average use of 1# of coffee or less per week.

But, ya know, I got these friends that hit me up for some bean juice & then want a # or 2 & I don't mind most of the time. But it seems like I spend a lot of my 'free' time, roasting for friends lately. And the drive belt took a dive on my Heat gun / Bread machine combo so I've made a choice to get a BBQ grill setup up & running.

Big difference roasting 4 or 5 # batches in 20 minutes compared to 1/2# batches in the same amount of time (rough estimate, weighing beans, loading, roasting, cooling, re-weighing & packaging). I have to say that I'm getting a lot of practice playing Ms Pacman on the xbox in my shop on roast days/nights  :D
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: cfsheridan on January 12, 2010, 04:50:02 PM
There are 2 bikes & I can only ride 1 of them at a time!

I've been needing a 2 to 5 # roaster for some time.

A really bad windstorm destroyed my last BBQ drum setup...picked it up and tossed it like a leaf . This one is going to be Heavy Duty, mobile & able to take a punch ;-)

The Hottop is nice enough, but I'm sure I'd kill it if I kept using it to roast 5#'s a day X 3 day weekend...I have 4 spare Poppery 1's as backup machines, but the controls were made by a guy that dropped off my radar screen 2 years ago...Fantastic controller. I have the plans, just need need an electronics guy to build me a few of them... :-\

At the moment, I still need a BBQ roaster more than a 'B' panel for the Hottop.


I've done 10-15 roasts a day over a 4 day period with no problem.  The P control system is a waste.  There's no level control of the heater--it's on or off.  Do yourself a favor and pay the hundred bucks or so and replace it with B panel--it will be like you have a whole new roaster.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Mlee on January 13, 2010, 05:58:42 AM


[/quote]

I've done 10-15 roasts a day over a 4 day period with no problem.  The P control system is a waste.  There's no level control of the heater--it's on or off.  Do yourself a favor and pay the hundred bucks or so and replace it with B panel--it will be like you have a whole new roaster.
[/quote]

What he said......
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: garybt3 on January 13, 2010, 07:41:42 AM

At the moment, I still need a BBQ roaster more than a 'B' panel for the Hottop.

I need bigger batch sizes. It comes down to spending less time roasting, more than anything else.
Let's assume that I need to roast 4#'s.
I can roast 8 batches in my trick P1. (8 oz batch size) 40 min to roast 1 # or 2 hours 40 min.
I can roast 8 batches in the Hottop. (9 oz batch size). Same result 2h 40m.
Or finish construction on a 5# BBQ Drum roaster. 30 minutes 4# batch.
I have 2 hours to do other things.

I never said that the Hottop could not roast 15#'s in 1 weekend, but I am certain that it's service life would definitely be shorter.
I bought it for home use of 1# a week. It's a good machine for it's intended purpose.
I've been roasting for 6 years now, started with a popcorn popper and still help beginners roast coffee with them. I have a GGSC Galloping Gourmet/Stir Crazy setup that's going on 5 years now. I have killed many Bread Machine drive belts doing 1.5# batches back to back for up to 10#'s in a single day.

http://sites.google.com/site/garybt3/myhottopkn-8828pcoffeeroaster (http://sites.google.com/site/garybt3/myhottopkn-8828pcoffeeroaster)

I want to believe that I can fully control it one day.


Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on January 13, 2010, 07:54:31 AM



I want to believe that I can fully control it one day.

sooner than you think ;D
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: garybt3 on January 13, 2010, 08:45:11 AM



I want to believe that I can fully control it one day.

sooner than you think ;D

You are (will be) my hero!  ;D
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: H-D Rider on January 13, 2010, 08:55:25 AM
Yes,  I've been anxoiusly awaiting word on the Millowidget and a recent post saying it may soon be reality for the HT and Ambex leaves me giddy with excitement.  I have both roasters and would be happy to take my place in line waiting for both. ;D
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on January 13, 2010, 08:58:21 AM
Gentlemen...Please stay on Topic.  This is the Hot Top Roaster Thread.  There are other places on GCBC to discuss air poppers, propane and BBQ roasters. Gracias!


Jake
Reddick Fla.
My great grandfather was an old indian fighter...he was married to an old indian...
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Steve7 on January 15, 2010, 11:06:03 AM
+1 for keeping on message!

@CF - you say 15 roasts per day?
How long inbetween dou you give to cool down?!
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on January 15, 2010, 11:13:27 AM
+1 for keeping on message!

@CF - you say 15 roasts per day?
How long inbetween dou you give to cool down?!
I try to let it get below 150.  Otherwise, the front half of the profile is behind and the second half ahead.  I usually choose the most convenient profile and let it cool.  Around 170, I turn it off and sit on my hands for 20 minutes before starting afresh.  This works for me, as I rarely do two batches in one day.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: lwharton on February 09, 2010, 06:45:24 AM
Sounds like you have the "B" model.

To lengthen the time between 1st and 2nd, you want to lower the heater power BEFORE 1st starts (I usually try to do this at least a minute before 1st starts) to around 50-60%.  That should give you a slow trip through 1st crack, and help get your total time between the start of 1st to end of roast to about 4 minutes.

CF,
I recently bought a Hottop B and am learning roasting profiles.
Do you ramp down the HT to 50%-60% for all beans or just certain ones?
Do your roasting profiles vary much from bean to bean as far as heat adjustments?
I am at about 3 min from start of first crack to start of second crack for most beans with about a one minute rest between cracks. Total roast times are usually between 15 to just under 17 minutes from drop at 200 degrees....depending on the bean. I am very interested in fine tuning my roasts from bean to bean.
Title: Re: Hottop
Post by: cfsheridan on February 09, 2010, 09:11:21 AM
Sounds like you have the "B" model.

To lengthen the time between 1st and 2nd, you want to lower the heater power BEFORE 1st starts (I usually try to do this at least a minute before 1st starts) to around 50-60%.  That should give you a slow trip through 1st crack, and help get your total time between the start of 1st to end of roast to about 4 minutes.

CF,
I recently bought a Hottop B and am learning roasting profiles.
Do you ramp down the HT to 50%-60% for all beans or just certain ones?
Do your roasting profiles vary much from bean to bean as far as heat adjustments?
I am at about 3 min from start of first crack to start of second crack for most beans with about a one minute rest between cracks. Total roast times are usually between 15 to just under 17 minutes from drop at 200 degrees....depending on the bean. I am very interested in fine tuning my roasts from bean to bean.

I'd suggest a higher drop in temperature, to shorten the roast time.  As for the profiling, I do it by bean.  Lower grown beans get a slower ramp at the start, in general.

My hottop has additional thermocouples I installed, for environment and bean tem.    I manage my lowering of the heat before first crack by watching the environmental temp--generally dropping the heat to maintain a max ET.

That's just scratching the surface though.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Warrior372 on February 16, 2010, 10:39:38 PM
Does the group have any connections with Hottop to get a discount on the equipment upgrade to the KN-8828P? $420 is a quite a price tag.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: lwharton on March 03, 2010, 12:50:36 PM
I am about to do a batch of Kenya AA to FC on my Hottop B. I have been dropping my beans @ around 250 degrees (per HT temp - I do not have any add on temp probes) and dropping the temp to 50% a minute or so before FC. My question is should I bring the temp back up at or during FC or leave it at 50% for the duration of the roast? And, what about the fan during this stage....should it be on/off or somewhere inbetween?

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Mlee on March 04, 2010, 05:47:16 AM
I am about to do a batch of Kenya AA to FC on my Hottop B. I have been dropping my beans @ around 250 degrees (per HT temp - I do not have any add on temp probes) and dropping the temp to 50% a minute or so before FC. My question is should I bring the temp back up at or during FC or leave it at 50% for the duration of the roast? And, what about the fan during this stage....should it be on/off or somewhere inbetween?


Speaking for myself I would leave the fan on around 25 percent once you begin to get smoke. I cut the fan on 25% and leave it there starting at 350. I cut back my power befoe first and usually just leave it that way until finishing....A lot is dependent on the ambient temperature as well.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: slowhand on March 07, 2010, 09:26:57 PM
   I'm a new Hottop B owner with 5 roasts under my belt. I understand the benefits of stretching the time between 1st crack and the end of the roast to four to five minutes. I have been able to do this, but not without roasting to full city or darker.
   Is it possible (or desirable) to roast to city or city+ and still accomplish this? I am trying to roast different origins to recommended levels as a starting point to see how I like them, then adjusting roast levels to taste. I do not roast for espresso.
   How important is it on lighter roasts to stretch the finishing ramp?
   Any feedback on how to do this would be appreciated. I know lighter roasts are harder to do, but I really need to learn how. I do not have any additional probes, yet, so I'm steering by sight, smell and the stock temperature readings.

     Glenn K.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: lwharton on March 08, 2010, 10:57:43 AM
I did a batch of Yirg and PNG to City+ on my HT and both batches came out with a fair amount of chaff stuck in the crack of the beans. Even a fair amount of agitation doesnt loosen the chaff. Is this normal? That seems like a lot of chaff that gets ground into your coffee.

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on March 08, 2010, 01:46:46 PM
I did a batch of Yirg and PNG to City+ on my HT and both batches came out with a fair amount of chaff stuck in the crack of the beans. Even a fair amount of agitation doesnt loosen the chaff. Is this normal? That seems like a lot of chaff that gets ground into your coffee.





~~~When my Hot Top B roasts are done I transfer from the cooling tray to a metal colander, back and forth and chaff is removed.  Most of my roasts go FC and on though



Jake
Reddick Fla.
Q: What's the difference between Obama and his dog, Bo?
A: Bo has papers.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Stubbie on March 08, 2010, 01:55:01 PM
This has nothing to do with a Hot Top roaster, but the lighter you roast your beans, the more chaff will stay in the seam.  The darker the roast, the more it opens up and releases the silver skin...

-Stubbie
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: cfsheridan on March 08, 2010, 02:06:49 PM
  I'm a new Hottop B owner with 5 roasts under my belt. I understand the benefits of stretching the time between 1st crack and the end of the roast to four to five minutes. I have been able to do this, but not without roasting to full city or darker.
   Is it possible (or desirable) to roast to city or city+ and still accomplish this? I am trying to roast different origins to recommended levels as a starting point to see how I like them, then adjusting roast levels to taste. I do not roast for espresso.
   How important is it on lighter roasts to stretch the finishing ramp?
   Any feedback on how to do this would be appreciated. I know lighter roasts are harder to do, but I really need to learn how. I do not have any additional probes, yet, so I'm steering by sight, smell and the stock temperature readings.

     Glenn K.

Slow down your roast prior to the onset of 1st crack.  Your entry point to first needs to be much shallower to keep that stretched lenght without taking the roast past City/City+.  City with > 3-3.5 minutes past the onset of 1st crack is tough, but it can be done.

Edit--with the stock thermocouple, make sure you're saving the city roast to later in your session.  Ideal would be that you've done the same bean, as the 2nd roast, so that you have some repeatability, and know when the bean is going to hit 1st crack, so that you can back off the heat ~ 90-120 seconds before that.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on May 21, 2010, 12:35:40 PM
Nothing to do with profiles or roasting per se: The display on my B model is a PITA to read with polarized shades unless you're right in front of it. I guess I need to get a taller roasting table? My rolly-table worked fine with the Sono, since most of the work was done on top of the taller roaster.

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on May 21, 2010, 11:47:32 PM
Looks like you'll be using an electrical extension cord with your new Hot Top Tex, is that right?  I see one in your pic


Jake
Reddick Fla.
If he's got golf clubs in his truck or a camper in his driveway, I don't hire him.
--Lou Holtz, football coach
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on May 22, 2010, 08:06:14 AM
Nothing to do with profiles or roasting per se: The display on my B model is a PITA to read with polarized shades unless you're right in front of it. I guess I need to get a taller roasting table? My rolly-table worked fine with the Sono, since most of the work was done on top of the taller roaster.


Get a chair?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: BoldJava on May 22, 2010, 08:14:45 AM
Nothing to do with profiles or roasting per se: The display on my B model is a PITA to read with polarized shades unless you're right in front of it. I guess I need to get a taller roasting table? My rolly-table worked fine with the Sono, since most of the work was done on top of the taller roaster.


Get a chair?

Wait long enough.  You will shrink with aging.  In the meantime, ship it to the Midwest for profile development.

B|Java
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on May 23, 2010, 07:22:49 AM
Looks like you'll be using an electrical extension cord with your new Hot Top Tex, is that right?  I see one in your pic


Jake
Reddick Fla.
If he's got golf clubs in his truck or a camper in his driveway, I don't hire him.
--Lou Holtz, football coach


That's a left over from the Sonofresco Jake. It's power requirements were a lot less than the HT.

I've got a spot picked out in the garage where I'm going to mount a powerful range vent hood, with an outlet to the outside. The HT will plug directly into a 25 amp GFI fitted outlet.

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on May 23, 2010, 08:21:00 AM
Roger that Tex, did you get the first roast out of the way yet?

Curious minds


Jake
Reddick Fla.
Pessimists by nature have a better time of life, as having our expectations dashed against the rocks is seldom a bad thing. On the contrary it is usually a pleasant surprise.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on May 23, 2010, 10:05:46 AM
Nothing to do with profiles or roasting per se: The display on my B model is a PITA to read with polarized shades unless you're right in front of it. I guess I need to get a taller roasting table? My rolly-table worked fine with the Sono, since most of the work was done on top of the taller roaster.



Get a chair?


Wait long enough.  You will shrink with aging.  In the meantime, ship it to the Midwest for profile development.

B|Java

In vino veritas; now just send me some of what you've been drinking so I can accept the
wisdom of what you say!

I'd love to ship it to you, but would you mind if I try a test shipment of lesser value first?
Say, 5 lbs of my premium Kitty Luwak?
(http://coffeefaq.com/luwak/luwak_files/Kopi%20luvak3.jpg)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on May 23, 2010, 10:07:34 AM
Roger that Tex, did you get the first roast out of the way yet?

Curious minds


Jake
Reddick Fla.
Pessimists by nature have a better time of life, as having our expectations dashed against the rocks is seldom a bad thing. On the contrary it is usually a pleasant surprise.

No, I'm hesitant to try - figuring I'd pooch my first roast I don't want to waste any of my premium beans. I need to find something I can afford to ruin? ::)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on May 23, 2010, 12:44:55 PM

[/quote]
No, I'm hesitant to try - figuring I'd pooch my first roast I don't want to waste any of my premium beans. I need to find something I can afford to ruin? ::)
[/quote]


~~~The Hot Top is simple enough to run for first timers which you are not...IMO, you will not screw anything up, measure out 280 grams of the Bali BM I know you have and get going!  March Mister!!!, times a wasting=:-)



Jake
Reddick Fla.
Presidency; An exercise in stupidity by a boy educated beyond his intelligence.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on May 23, 2010, 01:42:34 PM
~~~The Hot Top is simple enough to run for first timers which you are not...IMO, you will not screw anything up, measure out 280 grams of the Bali BM I know you have and get going!  March Mister!!!, times a wasting=:-)

OK Jake - I did 280 grams of Brazil COE #11 that I got from milo last year. Using your profile, I got a very nice FC before it dumped. Does anyone know of a way to remove the 356° & 410° deadman interrupts (they're a PITA!!)?

I was spoiled by the Sonofresco - it captured nearly 100% of the chaff - the HT ~50%. I turned my cooling fan to blow over the beans as they cooled and it blew away most of the remaining chaff. Not the cleanest roaster I've used - even the UFO did a better job of ejecting & collecting chaff!

We'll see how it tastes tomorrow!

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on May 23, 2010, 02:18:42 PM
Tex,  You don't need supplemental cooling w/the Hot Top.  Stop using your aux fan and you'll end your messy chaff problem

The deadman alarms will keep you from walking away from your roaster while it's doing it's thing.  God forbid if you started a roast, hopped in your car for a DQ and came back to the fire department hosing down what's left of your home


Jake
Reddick Fla.
If he's got golf clubs in his truck or a camper in his driveway, I don't hire him.
--Lou Holtz, football coach
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on May 23, 2010, 02:21:41 PM
Tex,  You don't need supplemental cooling w/the Hot Top.  Stop using your aux fan and you'll end your messy chaff problem

The deadman alarms will keep you from walking away from your roaster while it's doing it's thing.  God forbid if you started a roast, hopped in your car for a DQ and came back to the fire department hosing down what's left of your home


Jake
Reddick Fla.
If he's got golf clubs in his truck or a camper in his driveway, I don't hire him.
--Lou Holtz, football coach


Used my TurboCrazy & UFO for a long time without the need for a deadman switch. Guess it's worth it for those with Adult ADHD; not my problem though.

The cooling was for me - it's hot & humid around here today!

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on May 23, 2010, 02:41:53 PM


[/quote]
Used my TurboCrazy & UFO for a long time without the need for a deadman switch. Guess it's worth it for those with Adult ADHD; not my problem though.
[/quote]



~~~Deadman switches on plug and play home coffee roasters is a CYA for the manufacturer.  You'd be surprised how many users have caught garages, homes on fire while roasting green beans using these appliances, pre-deadman switches.  Home brewed roasters like your SC/TO carry no liabilty for anyone but yourself



[/quote]
The cooling was for me - it's hot & humid around here today!
[/quote]



~~~This time of year I'm roasting late at night for that very reason!



Jake
Reddick Fla.
Being in therapy is great. I spend an hour just talking about myself. It's kinda like being the guy on a date.
-- Caroline Rhea
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on May 23, 2010, 02:47:07 PM
Quote
Quote
Quote

Used my TurboCrazy & UFO for a long time without the need for a deadman switch. Guess it's worth it for those with Adult ADHD; not my problem though.



~~~Deadman switches on plug and play home coffee roasters is a CYA for the manufacturer.  You'd be surprised how many users have caught garages, homes on fire while roasting green beans using these appliances, pre-deadman switches.  Home brewed roasters like your SC/TO carry no liabilty for anyone but yourself



The cooling was for me - it's hot & humid around here today!



~~~This time of year I'm roasting late at night for that very reason!



Jake
Reddick Fla.
Being in therapy is great. I spend an hour just talking about myself. It's kinda like being the guy on a date.
-- Caroline Rhea


Wussy! If I roasted late the smoke might blow in my neighbors window and set off their smoke alarm. Whoa... Having the minister's wife running about in her nighties??? :o :o
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on May 23, 2010, 03:19:32 PM
Does she look anything like this minister's wife?
(http://true-blood.tv/Photos/Season2/files/690424_DSC_5615_thumb.jpg)

Jake
Reddick Fla.
"Don't blame me, I voted for the American."
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on May 23, 2010, 04:24:19 PM
Oopps!, bum pic, never mind=:-)


Jake
Reddick Fla.
"Don't blame me, I voted for the American."
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: lwharton on May 24, 2010, 08:17:33 AM
I have been trying to work on my dark roasts with my HT. I have been experimenting with Sulawesi and Mandheling since these seem to favor darker roasts. By using a combination of fan and lowering heat to 60% just before FC, I have been getting about 5 minutes from start of FC to eject. I am ejecting during a very rapid SC. For those of you who dark roast how does this sound? Is this too long? How far into SC should I go. Of course, HT will auto eject at 428.
Any suggestions on other coffees to dark roast?

Thanks
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Randy G on May 24, 2010, 08:43:43 AM
I have been trying to work on my dark roasts with my HT......  Any suggestions on other coffees to dark roast?

For a dark roast, five minutes from beginning of first to active second is about right. You might try dropping the heat to 50% at the end of first to slow things up about another 20 to 30 seconds total roast time. If you are getting about two minutes between the end of first to the beginning of second the lower the heat just before the beginning of second. But it also depends on how you got to first. For the last few months I have been taking care to slow the progress of the BT to 300 to give the beans sufficient time to dry, and that has helped improve the flavor of my coffee.

Depending on how you are brewing and your personal taste will dictate whether that is too dark or not. Personally, I don't roast anything I use that dark, even for espresso.

As I type this, I am enjoying a cup of pour-over Colombian that was a 12 minute roast, ejected just at the very first click of second... Smooth, delightful balance, smooth acidity, and a touch of natural sweetness... 
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: lwharton on May 24, 2010, 10:57:37 AM
Randy, thanks for the reply. I too have been trying to temporarily slow things down around 305 (HT temp display). I usually drop beans around 250 and up the fan to 50% for about 45 sec when the HT shows around 305....for the me thats about 3.5 minutes. I can smell the grassy moisture being blown out. Do you think 45 secs is long enough or should I extend the time. I also turn the fan up to 25% about two minutes before FC for good heat circulation and even roast....and then adjust it after FC to control roast time.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Randy G on May 24, 2010, 11:56:21 AM
............. Do you think 45 secs is long enough or should I extend the time. I also turn the fan up to 25% about two minutes before FC for good heat circulation and even roast....and then adjust it after FC to control roast time.

The fan is the most difficult control on which to comment. A lot has to do with your needs and even more so, the condition of the filter material. 0ne minute with a new filter is a lot different than one that has 25 roasts on it...

For my personal roasts I have been using the permanent type computer stainless mesh filter, but I have sound it flows too much air and I need to restrict it further. I have been using stock filters for the last three or four weeks doing testing so I am learning now as well.

As far as when and ho much to use the fan, I have permanently mounted two thermocouples into the roast chamber of a Hottop and I will be testing it later this afternoon. One is in the bean mass and the other above the stock sensor to monitor environmental temps. Having some way to monitor ET can help you a lot with learning the best use of the fan. And suing it in the drying phase to remove humidity is not a bad thing either.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on May 24, 2010, 02:21:22 PM

[/quote]
The fan is the most difficult control on which to comment. A lot has to do with your needs and even more so, the condition of the filter material. 0ne minute with a new filter is a lot different than one that has 25 roasts on it...
[/quote]




~~~I feel I'm getting pretty consistent results roast to roast cleaning the OEM air filter every 10 roasts.  I soak the air filter in a hot water/TSP solution for about 10 minutes, along with the front sight glass piece, bean chute cover, cooling tray and chaff tray (in a 5 gallon plastic bucket)...then a hot water rinse...and of course, the air filter is allowed to dry thoroughly.  FWIW I keep a minimum of two air filters on hand so I have at least one clean dry air filter to roast with while the other is drying

Works for me



Jake
Reddick Fla.
I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion. I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhauser gate. All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: cfsheridan on May 24, 2010, 04:37:51 PM
The stock filters will last for a long time if you soak them every 20 or so roasts in a cafiza solution.  I rotate about three of them, sometimes remembering at 20 roasts, sometimes not.  Machine just keeps on chugging.

Tex--as for batch size, I stick to 200-227g, as that gives me the most control to speed up as well as slow down the roast.  More than that, and I feel I have to run at full power to get to 1st in a reasonable time, which keeps the environmental temp (ET) too high, and makes it difficult to stretch between 1st and 2nd without lowering ET.

I run the fan at 25% at the start of a roast, bump it to 50% and keep it there about 4 minutes in.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on June 22, 2010, 06:56:10 PM
Has anyone tried rigging a replacement for the HT chaff collector? I'm thinking of a piece of thin aluminum formed to fit the hole the tray fits in, and ends in a round tube that a porous bag could fit onto?

That would be a lot easier to handle than the hot metal tray.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on September 09, 2010, 01:37:52 PM
Warning: The first time you disassemble your Hottop for deep cleaning, watch out for burrs of very sharp steel on the die cut edges. I just pulled a 1/2" long sliver from underneath a fingernail. I guess deburring and materials QA is where they shaved a few cents from their manufacturing costs? No big deal, just watch for the little buggers, especially inside the drum.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on September 09, 2010, 01:42:09 PM
Last batch: 09/05/10; 300 grams of Brazil Sul de Minas Canaan Estates

Target 424°F
Dumped @170°F / 100% power / 18:00 minutes showing
    Fan on 25% / @ 258°F / 14:30 - 14:00 to dry roast chamber
    Fan on 50% / @ 325°F / 11:50 for duration of roast
Power dropped to 50% @ 400°F / 6:15
1st crack @ 5:38 / 403°F (12:22 from dump to 1st crack)
2nd crack @ 3:36 / 419°F (2:02 from start of 1st crack to start of 2nd crack)
Ejected @ 421° (5 seconds into 2nd crack)

Results: Full City +, w/no oil showing 3 days after roast. Great in vac pot - lots of citrus & sweetness. So-so in espresso - not enough sweetness; maybe a little darker next time or blend with RSB?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on September 09, 2010, 01:58:45 PM
Last batch: 09/05/10; 300 grams of Brazil Sul de Minas Canaan Estates

Target 424°F
Dumped @170°F / 100% power / 18:00 minutes showing
    Fan on 25% / @ 258°F / 14:30 - 14:00 to dry roast chamber
    Fan on 50% / @ 325°F / 11:50 for duration of roast
Power dropped to 50% @ 400°F / 6:15
1st crack @ 5:38 / 403°F (12:22 from dump to 1st crack)
2nd crack @ 3:36 / 419°F (2:02 from start of 1st crack to start of 2nd crack)
Ejected @ 421° (5 seconds into 2nd crack)

Results: Full City +, w/no oil showing 3 days after roast. Great in vac pot - lots of citrus & sweetness. So-so in espresso - not enough sweetness; maybe a little darker next time or blend with RSB?

I've found the Sol de Minas is better after 5 days... give it some time and report back ;D
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on September 09, 2010, 02:29:28 PM
One of the reasons I got rid of the Sono was because I wasn't drinking a full batch (1.4 lbs) before it got stale. Now that I've got my Hottop I'm roasting 300 grams twice a week (1.2 lbs). Maybe I just didn't like what I was getting from the Sono, so I was drinking less coffee?

I do know that I'm enjoying the results of my roasting a lot more now.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Mlee on September 22, 2010, 06:23:37 AM
Variac question. When finished using the variac does it need to be unplugged. I have read both opinions on unplugging it and just switching it to the off position. Does it draw power in the off position or pose an electrical hazard. Any help appreciated.

Mike
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on September 22, 2010, 06:25:03 AM
Variac question. When finished using the variac does it need to be unplugged. I have read both opinions on unplugging it and just switching it to the off position. Does it draw power in the off position or pose an electrical hazard. Any help appreciated.

Mike
It's not a bad idea to unplug it IMO.  It should not pull current if off, but you never know.  Better safe then sorry.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on September 22, 2010, 10:21:45 AM
Variac question. When finished using the variac does it need to be unplugged. I have read both opinions on unplugging it and just switching it to the off position. Does it draw power in the off position or pose an electrical hazard. Any help appreciated.

Mike

Out of curiosity, I plugged my variac into a Kill-a-watt: No power is flowing, so off is off.

A mechanical switch can go bad, but not on its own as it sits idle. I have this argument with Mrs T all the time; a mechanical switch goes bad as it's flipped on and off, there's no way one is going to magically jump from an off-state to an on-state - it just doesn't happen that way!

edited: My variac has a light indicating when it's turned ON; does yours?

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Mlee on September 22, 2010, 11:48:19 AM
Variac question. When finished using the variac does it need to be unplugged. I have read both opinions on unplugging it and just switching it to the off position. Does it draw power in the off position or pose an electrical hazard. Any help appreciated.

Mike

Out of curiosity, I plugged my variac into a Kill-a-watt: No power is flowing, so off is off.

A mechanical switch can go bad, but not on its own as it sits idle. I have this argument with Mrs T all the time; a mechanical switch goes bad as it's flipped on and off, there's no way one is going to magically jump from an off-state to an on-state - it just doesn't happen that way!

edited: My variac has a light indicating when it's turned ON; does yours?


No, it just has a toggle switch for on and off.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on September 22, 2010, 01:13:45 PM
Variac question. When finished using the variac does it need to be unplugged. I have read both opinions on unplugging it and just switching it to the off position. Does it draw power in the off position or pose an electrical hazard. Any help appreciated.

Mike


Out of curiosity, I plugged my variac into a Kill-a-watt: No power is flowing, so off is off.

A mechanical switch can go bad, but not on its own as it sits idle. I have this argument with Mrs T all the time; a mechanical switch goes bad as it's flipped on and off, there's no way one is going to magically jump from an off-state to an on-state - it just doesn't happen that way!

edited: My variac has a light indicating when it's turned ON; does yours?



No, it just has a toggle switch for on and off.


If you're concerned about leaving it on, it'd be very easy to add a warning light - simply drill a hole and mount a panel-mount light wired to the switch.
(http://www.theledlight.com/img-JWRev/panel_mnt.jpg)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 04, 2011, 05:37:54 AM
I have a couple simple questions that are probably answered in the instructions but the layout of these instructions is not working for me....  :-X

Why do I have two different colored back filters?
When should I replace either/both filters?
What are the load parameters? Is it 250G without fail or is there some wiggle room worth knowing about?

I've tried 5 times to look at the book to scan for this info but it's organized more  like a novel or something and not like a step by step instruction book. I'm going to have to sit down and read the thing at some point but apparently I have attention problems.  :-X
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: BoldJava on February 04, 2011, 06:06:40 AM
... I'm going to have to sit down and read the thing at some point but apparently I have attention problems.  :-X

This is a disorder where the ability to stay with a theme is involuntarily interrupted; a cognitive disconnect, so to speak.  It is curable.  The disorder is knows as IHAFTMT, pronounced eye-half-tumt, meaning, "I hijack a few too many threads." Therapists often use cognitive behavior therapy CBT) for it.

A crash approach to CBT is SOT - stay on track.

B|T'erapy <grins>
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 04, 2011, 06:20:32 AM
I need bullet points and defined sections..

Any more if I am reading an email or letter that does not get to the point in 5-6 lines of text I just abort.


But hijacks are fine as long as there are fun things to see along the way until we get back to the trail.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: cfsheridan on February 04, 2011, 07:30:40 AM
Two filters must be a new thing--I've not seen it.

I think 250g is too much; I've had better results with 228g or less.

As for a simple profile: here's a start

Without adding thermocouples (which I recommend doing <g>), you'll want to preheat to higher than what the panel will tell you is the drop in point.

Figure about 250-300 on the panel reading, if the roaster is already warmed up.

Full power, fan 1 for ~2-3 min, then bump the fan up to 2 and keep it there.

Somewhere in the 350-375 range on the roaster, you'll want to back off on the heat to give a slower ramp into 1st.  I gauge it on my ET probe, and start slowing down to keep a steady ET.

When 1st hits, you should be riding 5-6 (+1 -2) on the heat, depending on the level of the roast you like, shooting for about 4-5 minutes from start of 1st to the end of roast no matter what the roast level.

You can also see what Hottop has posted on profiles here: http://www.hottopusa.com/profile.pdf (http://www.hottopusa.com/profile.pdf)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on February 04, 2011, 09:00:05 AM
I have a couple simple questions that are probably answered in the instructions but the layout of these instructions is not working for me....  :-X

Why do I have two different colored back filters?
When should I replace either/both filters?
What are the load parameters? Is it 250G without fail or is there some wiggle room worth knowing about?

I've tried 5 times to look at the book to scan for this info but it's organized more  like a novel or something and not like a step by step instruction book. I'm going to have to sit down and read the thing at some point but apparently I have attention problems.  :-X


Filter use (http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=4846.msg146750#msg146750)

Mine came with an extra filter too - you can keep on roasting while you're soaking/cleaning the dirty one.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on February 04, 2011, 09:41:56 AM
John,  Chad gave you some good recommendations on how to use the Hot Top, if you have it wired w/another temp probe or two.  Quite a few Hot Top users roll with a seperate (aftermarket) bean mass temp probe and also their own environmental probe.  But if you are running it stock like I have been with mine (for the past 300 roasts) you can successfully run with the default profile albeit with a few tweaks.  Like Chad, I wait for the temp to run up to around 230-240 before I drop my beans which equates to 16:30 on the time clock.  For 90% of the beans I roast I'm using the default heater profile and like it fine.  I also run the fan on 25% for the entire roast after it hits 325 degrees.  If it's cold in the garage (where I roast) or I have a slow stubborn bean, like Peter's Lintong, I may add time to the end of the roaster so I can hit 2nd crack.

99% of the time I start out w/280 grams of green beans in my drum.  I get a nice even roast.  What I do with the rear filters is rotate them.  I run one for 10 roasts then remove it and put a fresh filter in, and soak the dirty filter in a TSP/hot water solution.  Also, when I clean the air filter (every 10 roasts) I also soak the cooling tray, front sight glass and the bean chute cover in the TSP solution.  All of it is in a 4/5 gallon plastic bucket and fits nicely

When cleaning the air filter, all I do is let it soak about for 10 minutes, swish it by hand in the solution then run it through clear water to rinse it then let it air dry.  You'll know when to replace and you'll have plenty of warning to enable you to order spares.  Which reminds me, I need to order the small filter on top of the roaster, mine is shot

I personally didn't get involved adding temp probes to my roaster.  In my experience (300 roasts) my Hot Top B model roasts fine as delivered.  I only roast so I can drink and pull tasty espresso shots, like this one on the Salvatore One Black HX I used to own
(http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3154/4553256581_8630ee7b0a_b.jpg)
I can pull shots that taste as good as this one looks using the Hot Top default controls.  About this pic...bean is the Bali BM Draagoth distributed last year.  I took it into the front of 2nd crack.  The bottomless PF I had just drilled using a 2.25" holesaw and hadn't at time of the photo, finished clean the sharp edges of the cut.  This was literally my first pic using a bottomless PF.  At the risk of patting myself on the back, I'd say I have a pretty good handle on the PF side of espresso making (tamp and grind).  I've since cleaned up the jagged edges of the PF using a flat and round tail file, some emery paper too, then i went to work on the chrome plating using NEVR-DULL Magic Wadding Polish to remove the TSP stains           


Jake
Reddick Fla.
“Be Who You Are and Say What You Feel Because Those Who Mind Don't Matter and Those Who Matter Don't Mind.” -Dr. Suess


I have a couple simple questions that are probably answered in the instructions but the layout of these instructions is not working for me....  :-X

Why do I have two different colored back filters?
When should I replace either/both filters?
What are the load parameters? Is it 250G without fail or is there some wiggle room worth knowing about?

I've tried 5 times to look at the book to scan for this info but it's organized more  like a novel or something and not like a step by step instruction book. I'm going to have to sit down and read the thing at some point but apparently I have attention problems.  :-X
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 04, 2011, 09:48:20 AM
I will respond more when I get home but why a white and a black filter?

I'm not sure when to use either.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: BoldJava on February 04, 2011, 09:58:52 AM
I will respond more when I get home but why a white and a black filter?

I'm not sure when to use either.

Black when roasting at night; white during day?

B|Java
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 04, 2011, 10:02:26 AM
Black for covert roasts.
 8)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on February 04, 2011, 10:22:35 AM
Black for covert roasts.
 8)

Nah, that's when you use the camo filter. You did receive a camo filter, didn't you? ???
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 04, 2011, 10:26:26 AM
 Now I want to shoot off an email to score a silencer filter and an emerg self destruct filter in case my hide out gets compromised.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on February 04, 2011, 10:26:40 AM
So these two filters look different in colour but are the same filter shape and meant to be used in front of the rear fan right John?  Perhaps the vendor that builds the filter for Hot Top (or they manufacture it themselves), had different coloured material when manufacturing on different days.  If it's the same filter it really doesn't matter what colour it is.  I've heard of peeps using the Hot Top and not running the filter.  Me personally, I want to use the filter so the fan blades don't get mucked up from roast smoke detritus, plus the filter slows the roast down by regulating air flow out of the roaster (rear fan area)

now there is a seperate smaller filter used on top of the roaster...is that what you are referring to?



Jake
Reddick Fla.
I may not agree with what you say...
but if you say it with fewer words I'll try harder...  


I will respond more when I get home but why a white and a black filter?

I'm not sure when to use either.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: BoldJava on February 04, 2011, 10:32:54 AM
Now I want to shoot off an email to score a silencer filter and an emerg self destruct filter in case my hide out gets compromised.

Awh, man, the guy is 'jacking his own thread!

B|Java
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on February 04, 2011, 10:33:01 AM
So these two filters look different in colour but are the same filter shape and meant to be used in front of the rear fan right John?  Perhaps the vendor that builds the filter for Hot Top (or they manufacture it themselves), had different coloured material when manufacturing on different days.  If it's the same filter it really doesn't matter what colour it is.  I've heard of peeps using the Hot Top and not running the filter.  Me personally, I want to use the filter so the fan blades don't get mucked up from roast smoke detritus, plus the filter slows the roast down by regulating air flow out of the roaster (rear fan area)

now there is a seperate smaller filter used on top of the roaster...is that what you are referring to?



Jake
Reddick Fla.
I may not agree with what you say...
but if you say it with fewer words I'll try harder...  


I will respond more when I get home but why a white and a black filter?

I'm not sure when to use either.

Sounds like so much China-apologist BS Jake - most likely the manufacturer ran out of the clean white plastic and substituted the toxic-laden black stuff. :o

Have you registered as a Chinese lobbyist with Mr Obama's administration yet Jake? ;)

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on February 04, 2011, 10:33:53 AM
Now I want to shoot off an email to score a silencer filter and an emerg self destruct filter in case my hide out gets compromised.

Awh, man, the guy is 'jacking his own thread!

B|Java

OCD hijacker? The man just can't help himself! :angel:
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 04, 2011, 10:41:27 AM
Might as well have fun while we wait for somebody that knows...
 ;)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on February 04, 2011, 10:42:38 AM
Might as well have fun while we wait for somebody that knows...
 ;)

+1
Pay the man Shirley!
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on February 04, 2011, 10:51:39 AM

~~~this is not John's thread.  This is the Hot Top thread so to all, please keep replies related to the discussion of the Hot Top Roaster. 



Jake
Reddick Fla.





Awh, man, the guy is 'jacking his own thread!

B|Java
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: expy98 on February 04, 2011, 11:00:06 AM
I've been too lazy to add a TC to the bean mass but after trying
every which way from various forums on profiles for the HT B,
there are prob too many variables (voltage, weather...) and
I've finally settled on one profile that seems to work very
consistently for me, minor changes for different types of beans.

What worked well for others did not work well for me and what
works well for me unfor may not work well for you neither.  Also, I've replaced
the rear filter's white element w/ 2 computer fan metal filters (per Randy G), keeping
the black element, best I can tell, it flows more than the white element.

That said, here goes nothing...

- max time, max temp
- preheat to ~300F on HT display (typically at 22' remaining, otherwise I dump beans at nearest 30 secs interval
  for ease of log)
- dump 230g of beans
- Power 10, Fan 0 to start til about 3 mins into the roast or when I smell grassiness, then Fan to 1
- lower Power to 7 at 370-375F, depending on beans and past roast logs
- lower Power to 5 at 380-385, again depending on past roast logs
- Fan to 2 when too much smoke thru the top filter or when I want to slow down the heat additionally
- depends on the beans, may or may not increase Power to 8 near end of 1st Crack
- Eject based on either time, appearance, outlier of 2nd Crack or when it starts producing lots of smoke,
  again, this is based on past roast logs of same beans
- usually Eject around 14:30 - 15:30 minutes of roast time
- use a small house fan directed at the cooling tray

The above has produced the least (or close to zero) amount of tippings, divots and the best even color and bean expansion.

YMWV (your mileage will vary)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on February 04, 2011, 11:36:25 AM

~~~this is not John's thread.  This is the Hot Top thread so to all, please keep replies related to the discussion of the Hot Top Roaster. 

Jake
Reddick Fla.





Awh, man, the guy is 'jacking his own thread!

B|Java

\\:=|
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on February 04, 2011, 11:50:37 AM
John

This recent thread has several hottop profiles and tips that may help you.  Mine is included.

http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=10720.0 (http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=10720.0)

In my experience, lower loads and using less than full power (10) allows quick enough roast times AND low enough environmental temperatures to evenly roast without defects. YMMV.

edit - filters- I have three that I rotate for about 20 roasts each at whcih time I put the dirty one in a hot calfeza espresso detergent solution for about 15 minutes.  Wash well with clean water and dry.  They last through quite a few washings.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: staylor on February 04, 2011, 12:47:22 PM
I have a couple simple questions that are probably answered in the instructions but the layout of these instructions is not working for me....  :-X

Why do I have two different colored back filters?
When should I replace either/both filters?
What are the load parameters? Is it 250G without fail or is there some wiggle room worth knowing about?

I've tried 5 times to look at the book to scan for this info but it's organized more  like a novel or something and not like a step by step instruction book. I'm going to have to sit down and read the thing at some point but apparently I have attention problems.  :-X

I only have black filters. I rarely replace them, I've got hundreds and hundreds of roast on this bad boy and I basically use the same two back filters all the time. After one of them gets some accumulated roast deposits I take the filter to the sink and carefully apply some liquid soap then carefully scrub gently with my fingers and wash carefully under the cold water tap. Then it leans against the sink to dry.

I use 250gms. It's actually a decent amount as 2 x 250gm batches will roast out to approx 1lb.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 04, 2011, 08:40:23 PM
This was literally my first pic using a bottomless PF. 

That's pretty good if you ask me.

You had some early sprayers but everything pulled together very nicely in the shot.

My first few taught me I needed some distribution work I previously had no idea (how could I) that I needed to do.

On the added temp probes...

I won't need them. If I had to correlate this roaster to some other roaster I might but I don't plan on doing that. I can learn in a few roasts what the readings mean to this roaster and for my uses don't need to know if the temp actual is off by Xx degrees. I used to geek out on stuff like that but now I read over all the suggestions and what stands out to me looks like this to my mind...

Notes to self
Try batch sizes 220-260G and see what happens.
Dump in at higher temps than the preset suggests.
Slow down the heat before hitting 1st crack..
Experiment with fan for start of 1st crack but killing it between vs running fan from 350 degrees on.

That is sort of where I'll start either tomorrow or Sunday.

One thing I missed was about the top filter...

Do you guys wash that one too or just replace it after x roasts?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Igrind on February 04, 2011, 09:03:30 PM

~~~this is not John's thread.  This is the Hot Top thread so to all, please keep replies related to the discussion of the Hot Top Roaster. 

Jake
Reddick Fla.


Yeah!  What are you guys thinking?  The next thing we know people will be posting pics of espresso shots and describing how they made their bottomless PF!!  HT posts only!   ;)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on February 04, 2011, 09:37:37 PM

~~~That shot was built from club greens that were roasted using a Hot Top Roaster, so it pertains=:-) 

See here, going astray from the thread topic for a little bit is fine but this is a stickied thread peeps come to to read about the Hot Top Roaster, not rantings from some pablum puking liberal adult cry baby screming out wanting attention, Tex=:-)

@John F-  The top filter is disposable, the manufacturer recommends to replace after every 100 roasts.  I've neglected to so so with mine the last go around therefore a lot of smoke emanates from the top.  No biggie, I'll replace it soon

 
Jake
Reddick Fla.
I may not agree with what you say...
but if you say it with fewer words I'll try harder...



~~~this is not John's thread.  This is the Hot Top thread so to all, please keep replies related to the discussion of the Hot Top Roaster. 

Jake
Reddick Fla.


Yeah!  What are you guys thinking?  The next thing we know people will be posting pics of espresso shots and describing how they made their bottomless PF!!  HT posts only!   ;)


Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Igrind on February 04, 2011, 09:45:22 PM

~~~That shot was built from club greens that were roasted using a Hot Top Roaster, so it pertains=:-) 

See here, going astray from the thread topic for a little bit is fine but this is a stickied thread peeps come to to read about the Hot Top Roaster, not rantings from some pablum puking liberal adult cry baby screming out wanting attention, Tex=:-)



Gotcha!!  ;D 

I'm new here.  Just learnin' the ropes! You gotta cut me some slack!! :occasion14:
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 05, 2011, 06:37:55 AM
(typically at 22' remaining, otherwise I dump beans at nearest 30 secs interval
  for ease of log)
.
.
.
- usually Eject around 14:30 - 15:30 minutes of roast time


So your roasts are approx 7 min or so from dumping beans to hitting eject?

Am I reading that right?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 05, 2011, 05:03:29 PM

When 1st hits, you should be riding 5-6 (+1 -2) on the heat, depending on the level of the roast you like, shooting for about 4-5 minutes from start of 1st to the end of roast no matter what the roast level.

I just got my first roast in.

It took me 12 min to get from dumping in to onset of first crack and 15 min 25 seconds to terminating roast at outliers of 2nd.

So I think I turned down the heat too soon (I dropped from full power to 5 after 3 min into the roast) and once I came up to 6-7 I picked up too much speed and rushed into second a bit heavy on the gas pedal.

Next time I will drop from full to about 8 at 3 min then to 5 at about 5 min into the roast to see how that works out.

All in all I am happy with how this roast went and it looks great.

Some vitals to look at/comment on if you guys want are as follows:

Dumped in 250g at starting temp of 275
Hit first crack at 12 min.. temp reading 382  
Terminated roast 15 min 25 seconds at a board temp reading of 428f
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: staylor on February 05, 2011, 05:10:08 PM
Here's my comment... enjoy the ride.

By roast #100 you will have tried pretty much all the different kinds of ways to skin that cat. Eventually your profile will be 'do what the bean tells you to do'. ;-)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 05, 2011, 05:17:43 PM
I am actually at peace.   ;D
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: staylor on February 05, 2011, 06:29:33 PM
Haha, that's a good place to be.

You watching the fights tonight? I'm stuck watching it sometime tomorrow.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 05, 2011, 06:35:48 PM

You watching the fights tonight? I'm stuck watching it sometime tomorrow.

I am doing some non spoiler live blogging right now over in OT...

I will update after every fight with some comments that won't spoil anything for you.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: expy98 on February 05, 2011, 08:03:05 PM
(typically at 22' remaining, otherwise I dump beans at nearest 30 secs interval
  for ease of log)
.
- usually Eject around 14:30 - 15:30 minutes of roast time



So your roasts are approx 7 min or so from dumping beans to hitting eject?

Am I reading that right?


I can see how that might be somewhat confusing...

My total roast time is around 15 minutes, +/- 1' or so.  I've never logged the remaining time, only total roast time.
I use this roast log template:

http://www.avacuppa.com.au/mediawiki/images/5/59/Coffee_Roasting_Log.doc (http://www.avacuppa.com.au/mediawiki/images/5/59/Coffee_Roasting_Log.doc)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 05, 2011, 08:09:32 PM
My total roast time is around 15 minutes, +/- 1' or so. 

That is about where I landed...
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: expy98 on February 05, 2011, 08:22:56 PM
My total roast time is around 15 minutes, +/- 1' or so. 

That is about where I landed...

2 wrongs must equal to one right...
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: John F on February 19, 2011, 10:36:36 AM
- Power 10, Fan 0 to start til about 3 mins into the roast or when I smell grassiness, then Fan to 1
- lower Power to 7 at 370-375F, depending on beans and past roast logs
- lower Power to 5 at 380-385, again depending on past roast logs

I dumped in at 320f and used the above guide. I bumped back up to 6 power when I noticed the temp stalling after 1st and then to 7 power a bit later.

I like the way this roast went getting to 1st crack around 9 min and terminate at 14 min. In my limited experience with the HT dropping temp at 370 and again at 380 did help me get closer to a profile I (think) I'm after vs the faster roasts I started with.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on February 05, 2012, 12:24:54 PM
WHY ISN'T THIS THREAD STILL STICKIED?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: BoldJava on February 05, 2012, 12:36:07 PM
WHY ISN'T THIS THREAD STILL STICKIED?

It is.  What are you looking at?

B|Java
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on February 05, 2012, 05:08:08 PM
WHY ISN'T THIS THREAD STILL STICKIED?

It is.  What are you looking at?

B|Java

C'mon man, don't mess with da bull.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on February 05, 2012, 06:13:04 PM
I took my HT apart for its first deep cleaning and I noticed the drum motor has a lot of dark coffee residue on the top half. Is this normal? Should I try to clean it off? I wish I had taken a picture next time I have it apart I will.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico21 on February 05, 2012, 09:07:19 PM
I was cleaning my Hottop, and couldn't reach some residuals at the bottom of the drum.  Then I figured easy way to do it - put the drum in electrical oven and run self cleaning.
I came up with the idea myself, so don't quote me now some old threads or whatnot.

The only disadvantage is that the drum is not longer shiny at easy to reach places, but it has some kind of golden layer throughout.  But clean it is.

Miroslav
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on February 05, 2012, 09:42:07 PM
I took my HT apart for its first deep cleaning and I noticed the drum motor has a lot of dark coffee residue on the top half. Is this normal? Should I try to clean it off? I wish I had taken a picture next time I have it apart I will.


~~~that is normal, you can clean it, I use paper towel soaked in Joe Glo/warm water to remove this residue.  It's a PITA but if you keep at it each time you remove the rear cover to blow chaff off the electrical board every 3 months, your motor will come clean fairly fast, but skip a cleaning or two, and it will take longer to remove


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.
"As democracy is perfected, the office of President represents, more and more closely, the inner soul of the people. On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be occupied by a downright moron." --- H.L. Mencken, The Baltimore Evening Sun, July 26, 1920
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on February 05, 2012, 09:51:30 PM
I was cleaning my Hottop, and couldn't reach some residuals at the bottom of the drum.  Then I figured easy way to do it - put the drum in electrical oven and run self cleaning.
I came up with the idea myself, so don't quote me now some old threads or whatnot.

The only disadvantage is that the drum is not longer shiny at easy to reach places, but it has some kind of golden layer throughout.  But clean it is.

Miroslav


~~~here's another way to clean the drum....take a 4 or 5 gallon plastic pail and pour some TSP in it, add water (hot), place the drum in this solution, come back 20 minures later and use a 3M/sponge pad on it...the baked on bean matter comes right off.  I also place the cooling tray, bean chute lid, front cover and the air filter in this same solution.  Mix the TSP with water according to the ratio suggested on the TSP carton.  TSP (tri sodium phosphate) can be bought at any hardware and is most often used as a wall cleaner but it is also a key ingredient in most proprietary espresso machine cleaners, like Glo Joe, except Joe Glo includes some rinse agebnts in their formulation.  That said, I would never use straight TSP to clean an espresso machine 3 way valve, group as some of the TSP wont rinse out of passage ways you can't see, but when cleaning your roaster parts, those you can see and get your hands on, straight TSP is a good economical cleaner.  Also, don't forget to rinse the parts well after using either cleaner.  Others may have better and different ideas 


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.
An appointment is an engagement to see someone, while a morningstar is a large lump of metal used for viciously crushing skulls. It is important not to confuse the two
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on February 12, 2012, 08:14:44 PM
How important is it to keep the drum, etc, shiny clean?  I thought seasoning was a good thing.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on February 12, 2012, 08:57:43 PM
How important is it to keep the drum, etc, shiny clean?  I thought seasoning was a good thing.



~~~~IMO & experience, cleaning the drum is not critical as it is so close to the heat source, it never cools enough while the beans are smoking for soot to develop on it, but you should take the bean chute cover and clean it well, as well as the chute the beans slide on into the drum, but to do that the outer wrap must be removed.  Besides cleaning the rear main filter, what's important to do if you are using this roaster week in week out is to remove the rear cover and blow the chaff off the electronics board, and it's not a bad idea to manually clean the blades of the rear fan and the motor housing occasionally, since the soot builds up on those components <big time>


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.
Liberalism: Ideas so good they have to be mandatory
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on February 12, 2012, 10:36:51 PM
I remove the back cover and blow that out, then vacuum as much out as I can.  Cleaning the fan blades was not very easy.  I was thinking of just getting a new fan from a computer or electronics graveyard in the future.  Unfortunately, I think I stripped the threads on the back cover, so I will be reluctant to take the whole back assembly off again.

The thick layer of coffee lacquer that has built up on my chute cover was a source of pride and pleasure.  You're saying that is bad? 
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on February 12, 2012, 11:41:10 PM
I remove the back cover and blow that out, then vacuum as much out as I can.  Cleaning the fan blades was not very easy. 





~~~Yes, cleaning the fan blades is a thankless job but the soot build up impairs the motor's ability to turn the fan putting an extra load on the motor.  I've cleaned mine with a paper towel soaked in a solution of Joe Glo espresso machine cleaner and hot water.  It's tedious but gets the soot off



I was thinking of just getting a new fan from a computer or electronics graveyard in the future.




~~~I just purchased a new rear fan from Hot Top when i bought a new control panel board (to fix the sticking button issue), the new rear fan from Hot Top cost $25 & includes the plastic housing it is bolted into...plug and play as the fan wiring harness is set up for Hot Top's connector, but if you could replace just the fan for a whole lot less and splice it into the Hot Top connector, go for it.  I felt at $25, it was just cheaper to buy the new OEM fan unit from Hot Top, but I was already ordering other parts from them



  Unfortunately, I think I stripped the threads on the back cover, so I will be reluctant to take the whole back assembly off again.




~~~those 8 or so screws holding the rear cover are certainly a PITA to R&R w/o mucking up the heads.  I'm going to guess the head of the fastnerer is what you stripped?  I've heard of other Hot Top owners fitting different fasteners, ones with better heads that are not so prone to strip.  I've been aware of the difficulty removing them so I have been extra careful whenever R&Ring and they have not stripped for me.  Might be worth it to order 8 of those screws from them whenever ordering other factory parts and replace every other time the rear cover is removed as matter of course.  I know Hot Top includes new screws with their top filter and the fan I bought also included four new screws, and I tossed the OEM fasteners when I replaced the fan and whenever I replace the top filter, which has been 3 times




The thick layer of coffee lacquer that has built up on my chute cover was a source of pride and pleasure.  You're saying that is bad?




~~~I think it's worth cleaning from time to time to keep the build up from getting out of control.  What if a good sized piece of the build up breaks off, unbeknownst to you, falls into the coffee drum and makes it out of the roaster along with the roasted beans.  I wouldn't want that flavour going through my coffee grinder into my espresso basket along with the grinds I brew.  This is the same reason I remove the lower burr carrier on my coffee grinder every 2 weeks and thoroughly clean it, so the built up coffee oils that attach themselves to the fingers of the carrier do not make their way into my coffee. 
(http://farm7.staticflickr.com/6057/6321231107_50ee4808a4_b.jpg)
That oil turns rancid if left on too long.  The spooge on your bean chute cover and chute if flakes and falls into the roaster drum may burn up before ever making it out of the roaster, but why let this stuff mix with the coffee you're roasting in the first place?


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla. 
My great grandfather was an old indian fighter...he was married to an old indian...
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on February 12, 2012, 11:59:18 PM
~~~those 8 or so screws holding the rear cover are certainly a PITA to R&R w/o mucking up the heads.  I'm going to guess the head of the fastnerer is what you stripped? 

Nope, it is the plastic of the back housing that has been stripped.  Now, I turn and turn the screws, but they do not hit the end.  Removing is the same, I turn but they do not come out.  They are holding the housing on by friction.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on February 13, 2012, 01:58:32 AM
~~~those 8 or so screws holding the rear cover are certainly a PITA to R&R w/o mucking up the heads.  I'm going to guess the head of the fastnerer is what you stripped? 

Nope, it is the plastic of the back housing that has been stripped.  Now, I turn and turn the screws, but they do not hit the end.  Removing is the same, I turn but they do not come out.  They are holding the housing on by friction.



~~~I'd take one of the fasteners to your favorite hardware and get the next largest size.  It might thread in and hold.  If not, go to the size after that?  Let us know how it works for you


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.
“Be Who You Are and Say What You Feel Because Those Who Mind Don't Matter and Those Who Matter Don't Mind.” -Dr. Suess
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on March 06, 2012, 04:03:24 AM
How to stop smoke leaking through the HT bean chute?
I currently use teflon tape, wounded around the shute cover, and it helps but it's not perfect.
I am thinkig to buy hi temp (food grade, although not critical) silicon to make chute cover plug in. Or apply thin layer of silicone on the hottop around the chute.
Does anyone have some other solution implemented, or some other idea?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on March 06, 2012, 10:55:32 AM
How to stop smoke leaking through the HT bean chute?
I currently use teflon tape, wounded around the shute cover, and it helps but it's not perfect.
I am thinkig to buy hi temp (food grade, although not critical) silicon to make chute cover plug in. Or apply thin layer of silicone on the hottop around the chute.
Does anyone have some other solution implemented, or some other idea?


~~~Either your bean chute cover or the piece it sits on is bent.  Figure out which one it is (examine carefully)  and replace it.  You can buy OEM replacement parts from the Hot Top distributor (Michael) who lives outside New York City in Long Island (or is it Rhode Island?).  Contact Michael directly through the U.S. website.  The replacement parts prices are economical, he has them in stock, ships quickly...get going=:-)


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.
Our FREEDOM rests on 4 boxes:

Soap, Ballot, Jury, and Cartridge 
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on March 06, 2012, 11:25:18 AM
I have had this problem from the first roast and assumed that it was a common problem with all HT roasters.
I have new cover, let me investigate further...
Thanks,
Miroslav
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on March 06, 2012, 11:41:18 AM
Mine has done it since day one I also thought it was a common problem. I notice it more with dry processed coffee or when I roast darker.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on March 07, 2012, 09:30:11 PM
Just to share my current solution with the teflon tape.  I rolled several layers of the tape around the edges of the cap so that part of the teflon tape is under the cap and makes it air tight.Thanks rarebear to let me know that teflon is not healthy on hight temperatures.  Therefore I removed teflon, and use silicone baking sheet.

Also, I measure ET throgh the chute. 
Teflon tape on the thermocouple, as well as part of pencil, insulates thermocouple from the hot metal.  If thin thermocouple touches the hot metal it shows wrong temperature due to fast heat distribution to the thermocouple.

I like the fact that thin (1/8") thermocouple is much more responsive than more sturdy one (1/4") that I have in my permanent back-wall installation.  I will be using those inexpensive thermocouples at the end.  I will have to figure out how to avoid contact of the hot metal surface for my permanent installation on the back wall.  High temperature silicon might be usefull.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on March 08, 2012, 09:52:21 AM
To wake up lazy first crack, I quickly move filter up and down.  Obviously, as the air moves out, it passes just enough heat to other beans to trigger the crack.

I was looking to buy an electrical convection oven last weekend, and found out that there are two types: European (heat source behind the ventilator), and American (just add ventilator to the regular oven).

I have now crazy idea of adding tiny ventilator to increase air movement in the HT, and increase convection.  For testing, I will add it somehow in the chute, on the chute cover, and run with Dremel flexible drill extension. I will just need to find or make tiny metal ventilator.

What do you think about this idea?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on April 02, 2012, 07:32:57 PM
I usually roast 8oz batches in my HT but I would like to try 4oz batches for cupping or blending. Anyone doing smaller batches and if so any pointers or tips would be appreciated.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on April 03, 2012, 04:11:57 AM
I usually roast 8oz batches in my HT but I would like to try 4oz batches for cupping or blending. Anyone doing smaller batches and if so any pointers or tips would be appreciated.
I was getting 100 g samples, and it was tricky at first. I did 3-4 roasts with coffees that I know very well before running live.
I was using Roasterthing to follow the curve of my previous roasts, but essentially you have to scale back on everything: drop in temperature, heat, fan and pulling the fillter. Doing that I was able to reproduce the same results, and stretch after the first crack. I didn't help much except to encourage you to go ahead, I guess.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on April 03, 2012, 03:37:10 PM
I usually roast 8oz batches in my HT but I would like to try 4oz batches for cupping or blending. Anyone doing smaller batches and if so any pointers or tips would be appreciated.
I was getting 100 g samples, and it was tricky at first. I did 3-4 roasts with coffees that I know very well before running live.
I was using Roasterthing to follow the curve of my previous roasts, but essentially you have to scale back on everything: drop in temperature, heat, fan and pulling the fillter. Doing that I was able to reproduce the same results, and stretch after the first crack. I didn't help much except to encourage you to go ahead, I guess.

I roasted a 4oz batch today using your advice and wire temp probe snaked down into the beans. It actually went well I dropped the heat too much towards the end but aside from that no problems. I'm going to do a few more practice roast before using my actual samples but I think it should be fine. Thanks for the advice
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on April 04, 2012, 01:18:13 PM
I am glad I could help.
Regards
Miroslav
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on April 25, 2012, 09:01:18 AM
I usually roast 8oz batches in my HT but I would like to try 4oz batches for cupping or blending. Anyone doing smaller batches and if so any pointers or tips would be appreciated.

I just now see this.

My typical batch size is 170-175 gm. I find that profiling is much easier than with larger batch sizes much akin to changing the path of a Corvette compared to an 18 wheeler. I can vary the time to 1C and finish over a wide range and the taste in the cup is noticeable. If you look back by search you will find some of my profiles (maybe even in this thread). I can re-post anything if you wish.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on April 26, 2012, 04:54:22 PM
I also always run 170 grams, and get about 145 g roasted. I tried it first time after reading your posts in this thread.  Big thing for me is very even roast as there is no need to run on max power. I was thinking to add bigger fins, but at the end pound a week is what we use, and having three coffees to choose from is perfect.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on April 26, 2012, 07:37:01 PM
I have tried smaller batches, too, but went back to 250g batches.  I did not see any big difference in the cup, except that my profiles were all off, and I am too lazy to recalibrate them.  Then again, I have a "P" model, and it sounds like those of you using smaller batches have "B"s.  For example, on the P, there is not partial power setting.  It is all or nothing. (I wonder why)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on April 26, 2012, 07:46:39 PM
I did a few of 4oz roast after I wrote my last post in this thread and they turned out fine. I would not hesitate to do more if I needed a smaller amount for a blend.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on April 26, 2012, 07:48:40 PM
I did a few of 4oz roast after I wrote my last post in this thread and they turned out fine. I would not hesitate to do more if I needed a smaller amount for a blend.
In a "P" or a "B"?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on April 26, 2012, 07:58:11 PM
I use a "B" model.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on April 26, 2012, 08:05:17 PM
Just curious, then, what batch sizes do "P" model owners use?  Or am I the only one? ???
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: juker on April 27, 2012, 10:51:34 AM
“P” model here. Batch size is 225g.

Base profile:

243   1:00   0
297   3:00   0
331   3:00   0
340   1:00   1
369   2:00   1
388   3:00   1
401   2:00   2
415   3:00   2

I load @250* (front panel)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on April 27, 2012, 10:57:53 AM
“P” model here. Batch size is 225g.

Base profile:

243   1:00   0
297   3:00   0
331   3:00   0
340   1:00   1
369   2:00   1
388   3:00   1
401   2:00   2
415   3:00   2

I load @250* (front panel)

Aha!  225g is closer to my 250g than is 170g.  It may be a "P"-thing.

You load at 250?  That must take a while.  I usually drop at 180 or so (before the signal comes to an end).

Thank you!
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: juker on April 27, 2012, 11:07:20 AM
I like the dynamics of BT better when I drop @250*
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on April 27, 2012, 11:10:27 AM
I will give it a try!
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: juker on April 27, 2012, 11:31:30 AM
I dug up a graph for that profile. Darker line is BT probe. Hope that helps.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on April 27, 2012, 12:26:05 PM
Juker,
Your temperature controll looks very effective. 
Would it be possible for you to add Power and Fan levels over time?
Thank you,
Miroslav
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: juker on April 27, 2012, 01:57:57 PM
Miro

You are thinking in “B” model terms. “P” is a completely different animal.

The profile I posted is for “P” model. It lists temp. set, duration and fan speed for eight program segments.

You cannot change power in ”P”. It is only on/off by temp. Fan speed can be set in advance for each segment and cannot be changed during operation. What can be changed during roasting process is temp. set (within limits of each segment). Sounds primitive? In reality - not so.

I can see why people getting frustrated not getting out of “P” model what they want. Without BT probe and a few carefully recorded graphs I’d say it’s impossible. But once you get correlation between set temp., display temp. (controller sensor), bean mass temp. and inertia of the process you can do very efficient  and precise profiling.

I removed my BT probe long ago – no need for it (as long as batch size is the same).
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on April 27, 2012, 04:51:06 PM
Well, all I can say that you have nailed my favourite profile.
Curve is ideal, like from designer.
I yet have to master to drive my manual HT B like you do automatic HT P.
Regards,
Miroslav
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on May 12, 2012, 08:17:46 AM
I bought metal filter that fits perfectly on HT:
http://www.suntekstore.com/goods-10008829-aluminum_filter_dust_guard_12cm_120mm_for_pc_case_fan.html (http://www.suntekstore.com/goods-10008829-aluminum_filter_dust_guard_12cm_120mm_for_pc_case_fan.html)

First I used only the metal filter, but resistance is very low, and roasting was even dependent on outside weather as my HT is connected to vented hood. 

Then I decided to put back original black cloth, and resulting filter gives very predictable results.  Soaking in cafitza returns filter 100% efficiency.  I will see how long the cloth will last.

Yesterday I roasted 7 samples, all 120 grams using the same saved profile, and they all had almost identical temperature curves. After 4th roast I washed the filter, and continued using the same profile.

Here is how I fastened the metal filter:

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on May 18, 2012, 04:05:39 AM
After a week or two of roasting with the variation of Randy's filter from the previous po,t where only paper filter is replaced with metal filter, I can say that I have removed one unpredictable variable from my roasting.
Roast after roast, some 15 batches, very consistent and predictable results.
Air flow at different levels is pretty linear, so I can actively use all fan settings.
I will need to find replacement for the cloth at some point.
Until I find replacement, I will be buying filters and replace paper with metal filter. If someone will need paper parts of the filters I will be giving them for free.
Title: Those that replaced their Hot Top heating element, please comment
Post by: shakin_jake on June 14, 2012, 11:06:53 PM
I'm thinking the heating element in my Hot Top B may be on the fritz.  here's whats happening...

Sometime ago when starting the roaster during pre heat the circuit I have it plugged into in my attached garage will trip the GFI.  I'd reset the GFI, turn the roaster back on and all was well

Then it started happening more frequently and would trip the GFI several times during the pre heat cycle but never during the actual roast

Lately it's been happening a lot and tonight (an hour ago) it tripped about a dozen X's during pre heat.  well, once under way with 12 minutes left on the roast, the GFI tripped=:-(

Not wanting to write off the roast I dumped the beans out through the front cover after removing it, into the cooling tray and took them into the kitchen where I got out my largest frying pan and turned on an electric stove burner on high and manually finished the roast.  Nice exp. actually.  First time I ever stirred coffee greens on a stove top through 1st and 2nd crack=:-)  FWIW I placed the now done roast back into Hot Top's cooling tray and ran it through some make shift cooling cycles by running the cool down and going straight to hitting the dump button, that only runs for 30 seconds...but I stayed with it till it cooled completely

So I'd liked to hear from those that have had to replace their Hot Top heating element if your symptoms mirrored mine, or maybe I have to sort out a bad GFI

I have 427 logged roasts on this machine...I bought it new (3 years ago) and log each and every roast


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.   
Our FREEDOM rests on 4 boxes:

Soap, Ballot, Jury, and Cartridge
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: ScareYourPassenger on June 15, 2012, 03:45:20 AM
I would see how how many amps it is pulling before jumping to the conclusion that it is the hottop.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on June 15, 2012, 07:40:48 AM
Jumping to the conclusion?  Bad form sir!  A more gentlemanly approach would be to ask if I tried using the Hot Top with other house hold circuits.  How many roasts were you able to complete using your Hot Top before replacing the heating element?


Besgt,


Jake
Reddick Fla.
Our FREEDOM rests on 4 boxes:

Soap, Ballot, Jury, and Cartridge
Title: Re: Those that replaced their Hot Top heating element, please comment
Post by: jimec3 on June 15, 2012, 10:27:35 AM
I'm thinking the heating element in my Hot Top B may be on the fritz.  here's whats happening...

Sometime ago when starting the roaster during pre heat the circuit I have it plugged into in my attached garage will trip the GFI.  I'd reset the GFI, turn the roaster back on and all was well
Then it started happening more frequently and would trip the GFI several times during the pre heat cycle but never during the actual roast
Lately it's been happening a lot and tonight (an hour ago) it tripped about a dozen X's during pre heat.  well, once under way with 12 minutes left on the roast, the GFI tripped=:-(
So I'd liked to hear from those that have had to replace their Hot Top heating element if your symptoms mirrored mine, or maybe I have to sort out a bad GFI
I have 427 logged roasts on this machine...I bought it new (3 years ago) and log each and every roast

Best,

Jake


I have roasted well over 1000 roasts on my hottop without having a propblem with the heating elements.  I think amp tests would be more conclusive than a tripping GFCI.  Opening the back up would even allow you to Ohm test the element independant of other variables.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on June 15, 2012, 10:49:51 AM
Is the circuit breaker in your electrical panel popping or is the GFI switch on the outlet?  GFI switch isn't necessarily an over current situation.  It has to do with current flowing on ground (ground fault interrupter). 

My hottop doesn't have a grounded plug (3 prong plug) and so it should never cause a GFI fault.  Does your hottop have a 2 or 3 prong plug?

What I'm suggesting is it may be a bad GFI outlet or even mis-wiring of that outlet.  You can test the operation of your GFI circuit and if it's wired correctly with one of these, which you can pick up for $15 at any home improvement store. 

(http://lh6.googleusercontent.com/public/dI1o43eR-8TZJPXFqShg3xf1sUn0hfDvYii7ay9GD_-39tEaXJvEwMbM4lq8YV7yh8Mldsqer8mwwH4RZMz8jIYoLMFHIf5SC6GDNuvfUC9gPPwA7bx4OFlq0F_qW_zuHxmMDImTBka6TejR-_QaqYVLCZxdtOrI6xXpIefNsMZedUzJyH8x06fBo6LQ_lRpwpavewzqVynR29kw9oagOftJIAJI4RHivsqcbVSVAuHA28X5r5azwDWGMKmchhxPoz5Mq1nkfHGbRKaQUc1VhfDS8U7jLA) (http://www.google.com/products/catalog?hl=en&q=electrical+outlet+tester&psj=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.,cf.osb&biw=939&bih=563&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tbm=shop&cid=5917360384558955116&sa=X&ei=SHXbT9v1E-jg2QWrg9XYCA&ved=0CNEBEPMCMAA)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: expy98 on June 15, 2012, 11:05:36 AM
Smico,  I've given up on the metal filters.  I've tried doubling them up and airflow is still like no filters.
I never bothered to try slowing it down w/ tin foil w/ holes. 

I'd be more than happy to swap you metal filters for your paper filters but I think you are better off keeping them
because I anticipate you will go back to the paper filters eventually. 

I've used just the paper filter alone and it's worked well enough in a pinch.  But if you need closure,
I'd be more than happy to accept the paper filters from you.  Less washing...
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: expy98 on June 15, 2012, 11:18:37 AM
My GFI was tripping every time I plugged in the Caravel.  Yet never tripped w/ a double boiler pumper connected to it.
Caravel when plugged into 110v pulled something like 140w and I forget how many amps, very low, according to my
Kill-a-Watt.

However, no problems when plugged into a regular outlet.  Doug/OE suggested that it's possible that my heating element
may have some moisture in it from sitting unused too long and I should "dry it out" by plugging it in a regular outlet
for a while.  After a few times in the regular outlet, plugged it back into the GFI and it's never tripped again since.

Not suggesting your heating element has moisture, but perhaps try the same trick and see if it helps?


Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on June 15, 2012, 11:25:10 AM
My GFI was tripping every time I plugged in the Caravel.  Yet never tripped w/ a double boiler pumper connected to it.
Caravel when plugged into 110v pulled something like 140w and I forget how many amps, very low, according to my
Kill-a-Watt.

However, no problems when plugged into a regular outlet.  Doug/OE suggested that it's possible that my heating element
may have some moisture in it from sitting unused too long and I should "dry it out" by plugging it in a regular outlet
for a while.  After a few times in the regular outlet, plugged it back into the GFI and it's never tripped again since.

Not suggesting your heating element has moisture, but perhaps try the same trick and see if it helps?
It could be buildup of coffee oils... but this would only will trip the GFI if you have a 3 prong plug...
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: shakin_jake on June 15, 2012, 03:34:51 PM
Thanks for everyone's help on this, you too scare your passenger...I was just messin with ya.  Right.

So here's where we're at with it...we also have two chest freezers plugged into the same line.  There's one more 20 AMP GFI circuit in the garage.  When we plugged both freezers into this circuit, it too blew, so we isolated it to one of the freezers that would not blow this other circuit and it runs fine.  The bigger freezer that is blowing (tripping) the GFI, we ran that one into the house on a non GFI circuit and it runs fine

Thinking it may be the GFI and wanting to eliminate it from the equation, I got a new one from home despot, swapped it out, plugged em both back in, same deal.  We're thinkin' the big freezer is dying a slow death as the little freezer works on that line w/o blowing (tripping) the new GFI

Boss is taking (has taken) everything from the big freezer and is trucking it into another empty freezer up in the barn

Haven't run any diagnostics on this suspect freezer but we're thinking it's a goner, or one not willing to run on GFI, which all of these circuits are in the garage, barn

Yeah, I could omit the GFI on that circuit but I like the added measure of electrical safety.  Will probably spring for a new larger freezer over the weekend.  Thanks for all of the hep!


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.   
Good judgement comes from bad experience, and a lot of that comes from bad judgement.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: milowebailey on June 15, 2012, 03:42:57 PM
Thanks for everyone's help on this, you too scare your passenger...I was just messin with ya.  Right.

So here's where we're at with it...we also have two chest freezers plugged into the same line.  There's one more 20 AMP GFI circuit in the garage.  When we plugged both freezers into this circuit, it too blew, so we isolated it to one of the freezers that would not blow this other circuit and it runs fine.  The bigger freezer that is blowing (tripping) the GFI, we ran that one into the house on a non GFI circuit and it runs fine

Thinking it may be the GFI and wanting to eliminate it from the equation, I got a new one from home despot, swapped it out, plugged em both back in, same deal.  We're thinkin' the big freezer is dying a slow death as the little freezer works on that line w/o blowing (tripping) the new GFI

Boss is taking (has taken) everything from the big freezer and is trucking it into another empty freezer up in the barn

Haven't run any diagnostics on this suspect freezer but we're thinking it's a goner, or one not willing to run on GFI, which all of these circuits are in the garage, barn

Yeah, I could omit the GFI on that circuit but I like the added measure of electrical safety.  Will probably spring for a new larger freezer over the weekend.  Thanks for all of the hep!


Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.   
Good judgement comes from bad experience, and a lot of that comes from bad judgement.
Yep, that happens with freezers.  Often it's the start capacitor for the motor or the motor itself.

Makes more sense that it was the freezer causing it and not the hottop.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on June 15, 2012, 05:49:25 PM
About GFCI & circuit breakers.  (http://home.howstuffworks.com/question117.htm)

A circuit breaker is basically fire protection that keeps you from overloading the wiring. It trips if a circuit is carrying more amps than it's designed for, caused by either by plugging too many appliances into a circuit, or by a short to ground.

A GFCI is designed to save lives.  A GFCI monitors the amount of current flowing from hot to neutral. If there is any imbalance, it trips the circuit. It is able to sense a mismatch as small as 4 or 5 milliamps, and it can react as quickly as one-thirtieth of a second. (http://home.howstuffworks.com/question117.htm)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on June 18, 2012, 04:24:18 AM
Smico,  I've given up on the metal filters.  I've tried doubling them up and airflow is still like no filters.
I never bothered to try slowing it down w/ tin foil w/ holes. 

I'd be more than happy to swap you metal filters for your paper filters but I think you are better off keeping them
because I anticipate you will go back to the paper filters eventually. 

I've used just the paper filter alone and it's worked well enough in a pinch.  But if you need closure,
I'd be more than happy to accept the paper filters from you.  Less washing...
I just replace paper filter with metal filter and keep the cloth. I guess, what we are saying - you use paper filter only, and I use cloth filter only.
I have few metal filters, and they don't really wear, so no need for you to send me the filters.  Can you pm me you address and I will be happy to send one new paper filter to you?  I like that someone will find use for it.
Cheers,
Miroslav
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: ScareYourPassenger on June 18, 2012, 07:19:25 AM
Thanks for everyone's help on this, you too scare your passenger...I was just messin with ya.  Right.

I see your taking it back now:) I don't take forums as seriously as others so I tend to side with people just messing with me.

Glad you got it squared away and that your hottop wasn't the issue.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on July 26, 2012, 01:56:04 PM
I've been having problems with my HT lately for some reason all my roast are taking longer than normal. Can anyone tell me if this is a symptom of the top filter reaching the end of its life span?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on July 26, 2012, 03:49:15 PM
I've been having problems with my HT lately for some reason all my roast are taking longer than normal. Can anyone tell me if this is a symptom of the top filter reaching the end of its life span?

Summer tends to be a time when you get lower voltages at the the wall from your power company. Get a KillAWatt and check. This can seriously affect roast times. Roast early in the morning to get the best voltages.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on July 26, 2012, 04:09:01 PM
Summer tends to be a time when you get lower voltages at the the wall from your power company. Get a KillAWatt and check. This can seriously affect roast times. Roast early in the morning to get the best voltages.

I learned this lesson when roasting with a Behmor last summer. I now use a kill-a-watt and roast in the morning or at night my voltage today was around 118-119v. Thanks for the reply.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Mlee on July 27, 2012, 06:57:07 AM
I've been having problems with my HT lately for some reason all my roast are taking longer than normal. Can anyone tell me if this is a symptom of the top filter reaching the end of its life span?
As said it can be either a voltage issue or when the top filter gets old it shrinks up and lets some of your heat out the top.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on July 27, 2012, 07:50:20 AM
I've been having problems with my HT lately for some reason all my roast are taking longer than normal. Can anyone tell me if this is a symptom of the top filter reaching the end of its life span?
As said it can be either a voltage issue or when the top filter gets old it shrinks up and lets some of your heat out the top.
When I saw the red element through my top filter the other day, I grabbed a Philips-head and switch filters out on the fly.  It made a difference in the roast time and the end result.  The felt inside the casing was quite shrunken.  A little soaking in cleaner will put it back to normal, though.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on July 27, 2012, 08:23:57 AM
I've had two HTs and have done ~70 roasts total; hardly an expert, right? But one thing I noticed is how the roast profile changes with reduced airflow as the exhaust filters absorbed gunk.

I used a Kill-A-Watt & checked voltage at the receptacle with a MM, and voltage is never an issue with my electric provider. But if the filter is used for more than a half-dozen roasts without cleaning, the airflow begins to drop off and the roast profile follows it.

That's why I believe Randy's filter mod is a good idea, as it keeps the air flowing at a constant rate, so profiles remain constant too. I wonder if there's a similar mod for the top filter?

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on July 27, 2012, 08:33:10 AM
I've had two HTs and have done ~70 roasts total; hardly an expert, right? But one thing I noticed is how the roast profile changes with reduced airflow as the exhaust filters absorbed gunk.

I used a Kill-A-Watt & checked voltage at the receptacle with a MM, and voltage is never an issue with my electric provider. But if the filter is used for more than a half-dozen roasts without cleaning, the airflow begins to drop off and the roast profile follows it.

That's why I believe Randy's filter mod is a good idea, as it keeps the air flowing at a constant rate, so profiles remain constant too. I wonder if there's a similar mod for the top filter?
This brings up a question I've had every time I read about these permanent filters, and every time I opt to clean my filter instead of replacing it with a new one: What exactly is the purpose of the filter?  Is it to catch the smudge that clogs it so it does not clog the fan?  Or is it to keep the environmental air clean to breath?  If it is the latter, I think that gets negated by the smoke pretty quickly.
If you are replacing the paper filter with a permanent filter that does not clog, are you letting stuff through that the filter is supposed to filter?  If the filter is only to reduce airflow, well then, I can think of much better design solutions.
Any ideas?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on July 27, 2012, 08:44:11 AM
I've had two HTs and have done ~70 roasts total; hardly an expert, right? But one thing I noticed is how the roast profile changes with reduced airflow as the exhaust filters absorbed gunk.

I used a Kill-A-Watt & checked voltage at the receptacle with a MM, and voltage is never an issue with my electric provider. But if the filter is used for more than a half-dozen roasts without cleaning, the airflow begins to drop off and the roast profile follows it.

That's why I believe Randy's filter mod is a good idea, as it keeps the air flowing at a constant rate, so profiles remain constant too. I wonder if there's a similar mod for the top filter?
This brings up a question I've had every time I read about these permanent filters, and every time I opt to clean my filter instead of replacing it with a new one: What exactly is the purpose of the filter?  Is it to catch the smudge that clogs it so it does not clog the fan?  Or is it to keep the environmental air clean to breath?  If it is the latter, I think that gets negated by the smoke pretty quickly.
If you are replacing the paper filter with a permanent filter that does not clog, are you letting stuff through that the filter is supposed to filter?  If the filter is only to reduce airflow, well then, I can think of much better design solutions.
Any ideas?

That filter is the last piece of the machine, so it's not protecting anything inside it. Placed where it is, it can only have two functions; 1) keep the work area free of chaff/soot, 2) restrict airflow.

A mod like Randy's does a good enough job for both functions and is permanent. For me, it seems like a no brainer mod!
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on July 27, 2012, 08:55:15 AM
That filter is the last piece of the machine, so it's not protecting anything inside it. Placed where it is, it can only have two functions; 1) keep the work area free of chaff/soot, 2) restrict airflow.

A mod like Randy's does a good enough job for both functions and is permanent. For me, it seems like a no brainer mod!
Well, on my Hottop, the filter is the next-to-last piece in the machine, right before the fan, so I figure there may one more purpose for it.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on July 27, 2012, 09:00:43 AM
That filter is the last piece of the machine, so it's not protecting anything inside it. Placed where it is, it can only have two functions; 1) keep the work area free of chaff/soot, 2) restrict airflow.

A mod like Randy's does a good enough job for both functions and is permanent. For me, it seems like a no brainer mod!

Well, on my Hottop, the filter is the next-to-last piece in the machine, right before the fan, so I figure there may one more purpose for it.


 What would that be, keeping the fan blades clean?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on July 27, 2012, 09:04:22 AM
That filter is the last piece of the machine, so it's not protecting anything inside it. Placed where it is, it can only have two functions; 1) keep the work area free of chaff/soot, 2) restrict airflow.

A mod like Randy's does a good enough job for both functions and is permanent. For me, it seems like a no brainer mod!

Well, on my Hottop, the filter is the next-to-last piece in the machine, right before the fan, so I figure there may one more purpose for it.


 What would that be, keeping the fan blades clean?
Blades and axle.  If some of the oils got between the fan and the motor, it could gum things up and stop the fan, I should think.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on July 27, 2012, 09:42:00 AM
That filter is the last piece of the machine, so it's not protecting anything inside it. Placed where it is, it can only have two functions; 1) keep the work area free of chaff/soot, 2) restrict airflow.

A mod like Randy's does a good enough job for both functions and is permanent. For me, it seems like a no brainer mod!

Well, on my Hottop, the filter is the next-to-last piece in the machine, right before the fan, so I figure there may one more purpose for it.


 What would that be, keeping the fan blades clean?
Blades and axle.  If some of the oils got between the fan and the motor, it could gum things up and stop the fan, I should think.

Maybe Randy or someone from Hottop USA could chime in, but when I looked at the fans they looked pretty well sealed? Since Randy's been using the filter mod for some time I'll bet he has some insight into the mods impact on the fan's longevity.

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: jimec3 on July 27, 2012, 11:56:22 AM
the fans are cheaper than the filters
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on July 27, 2012, 04:17:47 PM
the fans are cheaper than the filters
Main fan from HottopUSA is $30, filter $10.  Or do you mean buying OEM?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on August 03, 2012, 07:44:45 AM
After replacing my top filter and cleaning the machine I was still have problems. To make a long story short I found out that the difference in 119v verses 122v is huge. The only time of day I'm getting my usual 121-122v is in the morning or late at night. I guess won't be roasting in the evening anymore this summer.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: ScareYourPassenger on August 03, 2012, 07:45:26 AM
Variac?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: YasBean on August 03, 2012, 08:28:14 AM
Variac?

Variacs are not cheap, but more importantly, they are big and do not match the decor.  I fear I would not be allowed such a device on the already crammed counter.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on August 03, 2012, 08:43:48 AM
Variac?

Variacs are not cheap, but more importantly, they are big and do not match the decor.  I fear I would not be allowed such a device on the already crammed counter.

Build a nice looking box for the HT to set on and put the variac in it?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: jimec3 on August 03, 2012, 09:11:21 AM
the fans are cheaper than the filters
Main fan from HottopUSA is $30, filter $10.  Or do you mean buying OEM?

I am positive the fan without filters would last longer than three stock filters.  I used green scrubby pads
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on August 03, 2012, 09:21:41 AM
the fans are cheaper than the filters
Main fan from HottopUSA is $30, filter $10.  Or do you mean buying OEM?

I am positive the fan without filters would last longer than three stock filters.  I used green scrubby pads

Sounds like a good solution (the best ideas are always cheap :) ).

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on August 06, 2012, 08:59:11 AM
After replacing my top filter and cleaning the machine I was still have problems. To make a long story short I found out that the difference in 119v verses 122v is huge. The only time of day I'm getting my usual 121-122v is in the morning or late at night. I guess won't be roasting in the evening anymore this summer.

+1 - This is now a given for me. Ideal for me is a wall voltage of 122-123 which drops to 117-118 under full power.

119V is very usable however- Drop your load to 170 gm - preheat bean temperature probe to about 350* or so before dropping the greens and profile from there. You can easily get 9.5' to first crack and 12-12 1/2 minute total roast times with wall voltages of 119. When it drops to 113-114 V during brownouts you can't get good roasts.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on August 06, 2012, 09:23:23 AM
After replacing my top filter and cleaning the machine I was still have problems. To make a long story short I found out that the difference in 119v verses 122v is huge. The only time of day I'm getting my usual 121-122v is in the morning or late at night. I guess won't be roasting in the evening anymore this summer.

+1 - This is now a given for me. Ideal for me is a wall voltage of 122-123 which drops to 117-118 under full power.

119V is very usable however- Drop your load to 170 gm - preheat bean temperature probe to about 350* or so before dropping the greens and profile from there. You can easily get 9.5' to first crack and 12-12 1/2 minute total roast times with wall voltages of 119. When it drops to 113-114 V during brownouts you can't get good roasts.

I remembered you suggesting 170g batches to someone here or on HB and I tried on the other day. It went well until the end I didn't slow it down enough and blew through 1C right into 2C. If I have no choice and have to roast in the afternoon or early evening I will do 170-180g batches. I've been roasting the morning and have no problem getting 225g batches to 1C in 9-10 minutes.


Variac?


No I don't think I need a variac I can work around the problem. Roasting in the morning is actually more enjoyable since its not as hot in the garage.
Title: Re: Hottop and colder weather
Post by: az erik on January 07, 2013, 12:46:29 PM
Yeah, it is silly that we all have to go back to 165, I'm now in the habit of blowing out the chamber to speed up the drop then wandering over to my green bean closet and weighing out a batch and writing down what I have put together, by then the Hottop is usually at temp again.

Ohhhhhhhh, that commercial roaster bug, I feel your pain. I'm sure my wife would be ok with a "real" roaster purchase but I'm still pretty happy with the Hottop overall.

I pop the green chut off and pull the chaff tray out 1/2 way. Convection takes care of the rest. Hot ait rises drawing in cold air from the chaf tray. I can usually drop the roaster back to sub 165 in 5 to 7 minutes. I pull the green chut when I eject.
Anyone know if this might be a bad idea for any 'suddenly' cool parts like the TC probes etc?

BTW I have to Variac my HT as well. My voltag usually sits at 119, under 'power' of a BH it'd hit 113. The HT will do 'btter at 115volts but not well enough to give me a agressive profile. With the Variac I set it to 120 volts under preheat, if it drops later I bump it up but it's not usually more than .5 volt drop from the variac. When I 'ramp down' the voltag jumps up to 125 or so. most of the time I leave it alone.

I would seriously suggest getting one, only plug it in when roasting, then remove for the 'decor'.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: az erik on January 09, 2013, 07:38:04 PM
"cooling mode"
(https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-k-XB_QiI5zQ/UO42wB5H5bI/AAAAAAAAI-Q/LyyXfkYcK08/s640/photo%25201.JPG)
From 402 to 160 in 6 minutes in 55 degrees. I'd love to not have to wait that 6 minutes
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on January 10, 2013, 03:11:24 AM
I think that goal for back to back roasts should be to keep temperature of the drum as high as possible (next batch of beans is about to be added to cool it down) , and that we need to cool drum motor and electronics back to safe temperatures to start the next roast.


I have extra thermoprobes on drum motor and electronics area, and my cooling routine for back to back roasts is below, picked up from my post on another forum:


I installed manual fan switch, with slight modification: in manual mode fan is connected to external power source. This adds more wires, but it gives me more room for play as it's completely independent circuit.

I changed my roasting routine:
1. Roast
2. Eject
3. Fan on manual, take the filter out
4. Take the beans to external cooler
(At this point temperatures of both drum motor and electronics are shooting up as selenoid keeps the bean eject door on the back wall open, and heat easily leaks behind the backwall).
4. Press POWER on HT display as soon as it shows up - power the HT off.
(Temperature of the motor now changes at rate of -4C per minute, which allows for 7 minutes cool down to bring the motor under 60C)
5. Prepare the HT for the next session: vacuum the chaff, save log, load template for the next roast
6. 7 minutes after end of previous roast, set fan to auto and start new roast.

13 minutes roasting and 7 minutes cooling allow almost 3 roasts per hour.
My goal is close to 4 roasts per hour.

Miroslav
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on March 09, 2013, 02:22:34 PM
I do not have a fancy computer controlled Hottop. I can't even get my installed thermocouples to work properly, after three attempts. Don't ask ... I am a software guy, NOT a hardware guy. If I had a Twitter account, all my posts would be #TC_FAIL.  :P

Every time I roast, I run a "dummy roast" to warm up the Hottop before actually roasting beans. I simply press start, and let it run hands off. This makes it easier to reproduce prior roast results, regardless of whether this bean is the 1st, 2nd or 3rd roast of the day.

I also run a stored profile on my Hottop B that overrides most of the automatic changes that otherwise occur. Those are when it kicks the fan up to 75% after a few minutes and later when it drops the heat to 80%. The idea of saving a profile is from this post by Randy Glass on coffeegeek (http://www.coffeegeek.com/forums/coffee/homeroast/610920#610920).
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on March 23, 2013, 05:21:25 PM
I saw this comment by Randy G. on HB about a larger capacity hottop and I thought I would share it here for the members who don't visit HB.

"It is very close. 1KG capacity. Hardware done. I was told molds for production of hardware are ready. Final programming for control and GUI being completed as we speak. I helped design the user interface, or at least went over the design and improved it where it needed to be. Difficult with the time constraints I was given (could have spent a month in it- had a few days). We shall see how much of my input gets used. Wanted simple thiongs like keeping the "STOP/EJECT" button away from all other inputs, etc. Has a lot of great stuff, but a few minor features I wanted not included, but that is life. Probably not ready for the show (ARGHHHH, he screams once again), but from what I know, at this point it seems weeks (and not months or years) away... We shall see."
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on March 23, 2013, 05:39:29 PM
Hard to believe this may finally be available:
http://www.home-barista.com/home-roasting/hottop-b-vs-rk-drum-and-grill-t25286.html (http://www.home-barista.com/home-roasting/hottop-b-vs-rk-drum-and-grill-t25286.html)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on March 23, 2013, 07:17:16 PM
I wonder if the new machine will have the "fail safe" automatic eject points? They're the only reason I got rid of my Hottops - I felt insulted that they saw the need to make them idiot-proof!
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: kboom1 on March 24, 2013, 11:18:07 AM
looks like it's going to be expensive, so I still havent figured out which way to go yet. how long do the elements last on your hottops?
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on March 24, 2013, 02:10:52 PM
looks like it's going to be expensive, so I still havent figured out which way to go yet.
I would vote for you to stand in line to pick up a used Hottop at a good price. I'm thinking of getting a second Hottop that way.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: Tex on March 24, 2013, 03:08:33 PM
looks like it's going to be expensive, so I still havent figured out which way to go yet.
I would vote for you to stand in line to pick up a used Hottop at a good price. I'm thinking of getting a second Hottop that way.

Or one could email Hottop USA and ask if any returns or demo units are available.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: kboom1 on March 24, 2013, 03:50:28 PM
looks like it's going to be expensive, so I still havent figured out which way to go yet.
I would vote for you to stand in line to pick up a used Hottop at a good price. I'm thinking of getting a second Hottop that way.

Or one could email Hottop USA and ask if any returns or demo units are available.

I was refering to the price of the larger Hottop when it's released,but good ideas about asking for returns or demos. Theres probably a long line. I think I'll call tomorrow. I'm using 2 behmors back to back now but elements seem to go bad after 200lb of coffee(recently replaced). I know the HT will give me better control but wasnt sure about the lontivity,should be longer than the behmor, looks like a reg.element.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on March 24, 2013, 07:46:48 PM
looks like it's going to be expensive, so I still havent figured out which way to go yet. how long do the elements last on your hottops?

I have seen people mention hundreds of roasts with no problems. Here is a post from someone with over 1000 roasts. (http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=4846.msg222859;topicseen#msg222859)

I wasn't clear in my earlier post - I think the new Hottop will be WAY too expensive. I do not need to roast a larger quantity. It makes more sense for me to have two of the current Hottop B-2K models.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on March 25, 2013, 07:23:01 AM
I saw this comment by Randy G. on HB about a larger capacity hottop and I thought I would share it here for the members who don't visit HB.
Question for the moderators - doesn't this deserve its own thread? Seems misplaced in Tips & Tricks.
Title: Filter confusion
Post by: rgrosz78 on April 12, 2013, 02:09:19 PM
When I purchased my Hottop, I bought two spare filters for the rear, and the one for the top. One of my top filters has shrunk to half-size, so I need to buy a replacement. I have been rotating my rear filter every six roasts, and the top filter every 24 roasts. So far I have 132 roasts on the Hottop.

Based on some extended roast times, I probably messed up one of the rear filters during my routine "rinse and repeat" cleaning procedure, so I tossed it out:
Filters- I have three that I rotate for about 20 roasts each at whcih time I put the dirty one in a hot calfeza espresso detergent solution for about 15 minutes.  Wash well with clean water and dry.  They last through quite a few washings.

I went back and re-re-re-read the earlier messages, but I'm still confused. Different ideas have been mentioned for replacing each filter. Has anyone else been happy with the replacement of the rear fan filter material? Which green scrubby pads can withstand 400º F?
What worked well for others did not work well for me and what works well for me unfor may not work well for you neither.  Also, I've replaced the rear filter's white element w/ 2 computer fan metal filters (per Randy G), keeping the black element, best I can tell, it flows more than the white element.
I am positive the fan without filters would last longer than three stock filters.  I used green scrubby pads

I did not see any discussion about replacement for the top filter ($11). That seems far less important to the roast. I assume the top filter only limits the particulates in the smoke coming from the Hottop's hot top.
Title: Re: Filter confusion
Post by: rgrosz78 on May 12, 2013, 02:32:46 PM
I did not see any discussion about replacement for the top filter ($11). That seems far less important to the roast. I assume the top filter only limits the particulates in the smoke coming from the Hottop's hot top.

Randy G responded to a post about the top filter at Home-Barista (http://www.home-barista.com/home-roasting/hottop-top-filter-t25804.html):
"The material in the top filter, particularly used ones, is quite fragile. Unless it is damaged or particularly filthy, leave it. You can inspect it by removing the two little screws and taking it out as a unit. Look underneath as the filter material is exposed there. You can replace it with a cut piece of the black stuff from a used rear filter if need be."

Luckily I saved my defective rear filter, which I have now cut up, and discarded the paper part. I plan to use the black material the next time I need to replace my top filter.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on May 15, 2013, 06:06:54 PM
The top filter IMO serves no purpose other than to remove smoke. I insulated my unit about three years ago and I have that area covered with a removable piece of insulation. There are pictures and discussion here on GCBC somewhere if you can find it. If anything that configuration helps roast times by preventing some heat loss out the top.

I'm happy to send you a piece of my insulation material covered on one side with high temperature foil tape if you want to try it.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on May 16, 2013, 05:21:35 AM
Thanks for the offer. I have enough of the black material from the old rear filter to last me  several years!
Title: Re: Filter confusion
Post by: smico on May 16, 2013, 09:57:28 AM
I am positive the fan without filters would last longer than three stock filters.  I used green scrubby pads
I also use scrubby pads.  After 20 roasts or so, I put them in caffitza, and then they are like new. 
Trouble is that due to low resistance, you need to adjust all profiles.
I am happy with that solution.
Miroslav
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on June 18, 2013, 07:37:53 PM
I wanted to follow up with my results after replacing both my rear and top filters. My roasts have gotten SO fast I must adjust all my profiles.

Here are two roasts of some Ethiopia Sidamo from Theta Ridge. I did not make any change to the profile for this bean. Normally I would roast to 1C + 2:30, but I had to eject the beans at 1C + 2:00.

Prior roast - 265g - 01/05/2013 - old filters
Code: [Select]
DISPLAY      ROR
TIME TEMP FAN HEAT Milestone     per min
0:00 215 0% 100% drop 265g beans into roaster
8:35 320 25% 100%
10:30 350 50% 80%
12:50 381 50% 70% First crack
13:20 386 75% 40% 1C + :30
13:50 390 75% 30% 1C + 1:00 9
14:20 393 75% 30% 1C + 1:30 7
14:50 397 50% 30% 1C + 2:00 7
15:20 399 EJECT 1C + 2:30 8


Recent roast - 265g - 06/08/2013 - new filters
Code: [Select]
DISPLAY      ROR
TIME TEMP FAN HEAT Milestone     per min
0:00 215 0% 100% drop 265g beans into roaster
8:05 320 25% 100%
9:55 350 50% 80%
11:55 383 80% 70% First crack
12:25 388 75% 30% 1C + :30
12:55 395 25% 30% 1C + 1:00 12
13:25 399 25% 30% 1C + 1:30 11
13:55 406 EJECT 1C + 2:00 11
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on June 18, 2013, 07:42:40 PM
Here are two roasts of some Yemen Mokha from Sweet Maria's. Based on the results of the Sidamo roast, I DID make changes to the profile for this bean.

This allowed me to roast the bean to 1C + 2:30, but the roast was two minutes shorter. This time I roasted 30g less, which had a small impact on the roast times.

Prior roast - 265g - 01/05/2013 - old filters
Code: [Select]
DISPLAY      ROR
TIME TEMP FAN HEAT Milestone     per min
0:00 215 0% 100% drop 265g beans into roaster
9:10 320 25% 100%
11:00 350 50% 80%
13:40 388 50% 70% First crack
14:10 393 75% 40% 1C + :30
14:40 397 75% 30% 1C + 1:00 9
15:10 404 75% 30% 1C + 1:30 11
15:40 408 50% 20% 1C + 2:00 11
16:10 413 EJECT 1C + 2:30 9

Recent roast - 230g - 06/08/2013 - new filters
Code: [Select]
DISPLAY      ROR
TIME TEMP FAN HEAT Milestone     per min
0:00 215 0% 100% drop 230g beans into roaster
7:50 320 25% 100%
9:30 350 50% 70%
11:30 384 70% 50% First crack
12:00 392 75% 30% 1C + :30
12:30 397 25% 30% 1C + 1:00 13
13:00 402 25% 30% 1C + 1:30 10
13:30 408 25% 30% 1C + 2:00 11
14:00 411 EJECT 1C + 2:30 9
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on June 19, 2013, 11:54:42 AM
The top filter IMO serves no purpose other than to remove smoke. I insulated my unit about three years ago and I have that area covered with a removable piece of insulation. There are pictures and discussion here on GCBC somewhere if you can find it. If anything that configuration helps roast times by preventing some heat loss out the top.
I forgot to mention - most of the impact on my roasts was due to replacement of the top filter. I was pretty happy with my maintenance for the rear filters. It appears I was losing LOTS of heat from the top filter, since it had shrunk to 1/2 the original size.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on October 05, 2013, 05:26:00 AM
Last night on HRO, Ciel published piece on ultimate Hottop modification:


Quote Ciel: With a bit of time and effort, I have been able to transform my excellent "Home Roaster" into a wonderful "Mini Commercial Roaster".

Check it out Hottop owners...

Regards,

Miroslav
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on November 13, 2013, 03:31:05 PM
I've been playing around with my HotTop roaster top filter and bean roasting chute to get better heat retention. Several years ago I started a thread somewhere back in this forum about my insulation project. It's worked out nicely and this material is what I used to insulate the outside of the roaster.


http://www.mcmaster.com/#9323k21/=pd7no1 (http://www.mcmaster.com/#9323k21/=pd7no1)

I took some of this insulation and cut it into strips that could fit into the top filter to replace the material in there. I put two layers of insulation in there and it fit very well. I had also since the start of that insulation project just put a piece of insulation material on top of the filter and held it in place with a small wash towel. I wanted a cleaner solution and this seems to work really well after roasting tonight. For the bean chute I wanted to minimize smoke and heat loss out of the chute. I cut out a hole in a silicon baking sheet so the bean chute cover with my thermocouple probes fit snugly and taped it down with my heat resistant metal foil tape. That mod worked OK tonight and did minimize but not eliminate smoke coming out but I'm not sure about the longevity.

One preliminary finding is a hunch that the fan produced a more conductive effect on heat flow through the drum instead of acting totally like a brake on the roast.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on November 13, 2013, 04:16:42 PM
Good question Chris. Not that I am aware. The material is different in texture and consistency then the thick airy pink type fiberglass insulation. It is more like a thick cardboard sheet. However, I coat all outside exposed surfaces with foil tape.

Here is the original insulation thread with photos of my roaster.
http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=10633.15 (http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=10633.15)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on December 06, 2013, 07:18:29 PM
FYI, there is a new 0.7.1 version of the artisan software available (http://code.google.com/p/artisan/downloads/list). And Barrie wrote some very nice documentation (http://www.homeroasters.org/php/downloads.php?cat_id=1&download_id=24) on it, as well as using the HTC controller board. I did a quick read, and this helped me find the new features - will use it tomorrow.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on December 07, 2013, 10:58:08 AM
I've resisted the urge to look into these programs and the computerized profiling. I sit by the roaster and manually adjust my preheat power levels and roast power and fan depending on environmental signals such as the line voltage at the time, temperature out where the roaster is sitting and even the wind hitting the roaster -which itself is insulated.  I've found that all of these factors play a really big role in roast times and profiles with a roaster subject to varying outside environments. I can pretty much make up for any outside influences and get reproducible roasts but I have to pay attention. I think the computerized profiling would be great for a roaster in a controlled room but I can't do that right now. If the computer could adjust heat and fan on the fly and make sure to hit 300* at X time and 400* at Y while lowering heat at 380* etc. then you have a really refined control system.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on December 07, 2013, 12:16:50 PM
Artisan software gives me better information on progress of the roast, with ability to compare prior roasts. I don't have the HTC controller board yet - but I plan to do so next year. I won't forget what I have learned about roasting "by hand".
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on December 07, 2013, 01:22:06 PM
Rick

I don't know much about the various boards and software so I ask if the resulting roaster is more of an advanced P model where you are "stuck" with the program once it starts or if you can over-ride manually to adjust for outside factors such as voltage changes, temperature or wind and then let the program finish from there?

Thanks

Geoffrey
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on December 07, 2013, 05:13:32 PM
Geoffrey,

You have full control to manually overwrite automated profiles.

1. Both Roastlogger and Artisan, have sliders to manually adjust heat and fan throughout the automated roast. 
2. On my Hottop B2, all original HT controls function normally throughout the roast.
3. I always roast full 250g batches, and temperature in garage can vary greatly (5C to 25C), so I use variac to compensate for external temperature differences.


With all that control, I am able to replay saved roasts, meaning PERFECTLY replicate ET an BT temperature curves almost always.
 

To make replay more consistent:
1. Hottop behaves differently when roaster is warm or cold at start, so different profiles should be used for warm or cold start.
2. I use very low resistant filter (scotch-bride scrubbing pad) to get more responsive control and avoid air resistance changes.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on December 08, 2013, 12:26:38 PM
Thanks for that review. I guess I need to do some homework but right now what my roaster needs is a good breakdown and cleaning and perhaps new heTing element after five years.

Most of my shopping is for others right now except for a few straight razors soaps and honing stones. ;D
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on December 19, 2013, 01:28:00 PM
Artisan software gives me better information on progress of the roast, with ability to compare prior roasts. I don't have the HTC controller board yet - but I plan to do so next year. I won't forget what I have learned about roasting "by hand".

I uploaded a 10 second video to show the NEW items displayed in artisan version 0.7.1. Near the top of the screen are three separate timers for
Temperature at turning point is shown at bottom of BT curve. Sorry, but my vertical axis starts at 160 F, and does not display it fully.

Edited 12/29 - corrected description of "drying time"

www.youtube.com/watch?v=2T2bKtQs7PQ (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2T2bKtQs7PQ#)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on February 27, 2014, 06:56:48 AM
Artisan software gives me better information on progress of the roast, with ability to compare prior roasts. I don't have the HTC controller board yet - but I plan to do so next year. I won't forget what I have learned about roasting "by hand".

The hardware to control the Hottop (from Jim Galt) (http://www.mlgp-llc.com/htri/index.html) became available in February. I just ordered it today.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: jimbo on March 17, 2014, 09:26:11 AM
I have one of the older 8828D models that has been relegated to the back of the shelf to be pulled out only occasionally when I want to roast a smaller batch than my Sono does.

I'm considering upgrading the roaster so that I can have more control and work with it and learn from it before I go big.  It looks like for $320 I can take the roaster to 8828B-2 and possibly for a few $$ more take it to 8828B-2K.

Has anyone done this upgrade (or similar?) Do you feel like it was worth it?  For anyone with the B-2 or B-2K do you feel like you have, more-or-less, full control over the roast?

Any input is appreciated.

Thanks,

Jimbo
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on March 17, 2014, 09:34:54 AM
Artisan software gives me better information on progress of the roast, with ability to compare prior roasts. I don't have the HTC controller board yet - but I plan to do so next year. I won't forget what I have learned about roasting "by hand".

The hardware to control the Hottop (from Jim Galt) ([url]http://www.mlgp-llc.com/htri/index.html[/url]) became available in February. I just ordered it today.


How did the install go? I already have temp probes installed and I'm considering installing a HT/TC4. I'm interested in hearing your feedback on how difficult the install was.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on March 17, 2014, 06:46:19 PM
The hardware to control the Hottop (from Jim Galt) ([url]http://www.mlgp-llc.com/htri/index.html[/url]) became available in February. I just ordered it today.

How did the install go? I already have temp probes installed and I'm considering installing a HT/TC4. I'm interested in hearing your feedback on how difficult the install was.

Nothing to to report yet - I won't get to install it until mid-April. I barely have enough time for roasting coffee now ...
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on March 18, 2014, 02:49:51 AM
I'm considering upgrading the roaster so that I can have more control and work with it and learn from it before I go big.  It looks like for $320 I can take the roaster to 8828B-2 and possibly for a few $$ more take it to 8828B-2K.
Jimbo,
JimG has an older model and you should ask him if your HT supports the TC4C + HTC as is.  If not, go for the cheapest upgrade option.  After you plug in the new controller only one HT profile is used: 100% Fan and 100% Heat, and profiling is done with Artisan or Roastlogger.
Coupled with low resistance filter (I use Scotch-Brite scour pad), you can have very precise control of your roast, and replay to repeat previously saved roasts with almost perfect curve tracking.
I roast from 100 to 300 grams, but I have to pump up the power with variac for higher loads.
Let me know if you have any questions.
Miroslav
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: jimbo on March 18, 2014, 06:49:09 AM
Thanks Miroslav.  That's great information.  Based on the web site it looks like the upgrade can be done to my machine.  I was wondering if it would give me the control I'm looking for, and meant to ask that in my original email.  It looks to be quite a bit less expensive than going the Hottop route.

Thanks again!

Jimbo
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on March 18, 2014, 02:09:59 PM
Has anyone done this upgrade (or similar?) Do you feel like it was worth it?  For anyone with the B-2 or B-2K do you feel like you have, more-or-less, full control over the roast?

The TC4C + HTC gives you even more control than the full manual control of a Hottop B-2K. For example, you can control the both the power and the fan in 10% increments. The standard B-2K only allows 25% increments for the fan.

Another GCBC user (Barrie) has created a guide for controlling the HotTop via the artisan software and the TC4C + HTC board. It is available in the downloads section of the homeroasters web site (http://www.homeroasters.org/php/downloads.php?cat_id=1&download_id=25).

Check out Jim Galt's Users Guide (http://www.mlgp-llc.com/htri/pdf/HTRI-UserGuide-v100.pdf) for more details on on the installation of the TC4C + HTC board inside the HotTop.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on March 18, 2014, 04:23:15 PM
Jimbo,

This is not fair comparison because original HT automation ends at three time based profiles.
TC4 + HTC + Artisan or Roastlogger will give you full control of your roast. You can save every roast, and later on replay it. There is a learning curve, of course, but I can assure you that you will be able to achieve perfect curve overlap over the template roast. I was even roasting 60g for cupping. You controll fan and heat with 1% increments, although fan control is not as precise.

Automation is based on ingenious setup that I first saw in Roastlogger:
Up to the first crack triggers are fired based on BT
After FC triggers are fired based on time from the FC.

As I said previously, if you can go without wasting money on HT upgrade, go for the TC4 + HTC. Do check with JimG first though. He is great guy, busy at times, but aren't we all.

Look up at Homeroaster forum. I read about some new product that use native USB communication, not serial port communication...

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: az erik on March 20, 2014, 12:01:58 PM
Jimbo,

As I said previously, if you can go without wasting money on HT upgrade, go for the TC4 + HTC. Do check with JimG first though. He is great guy, busy at times, but aren't we all.

Look up at Homeroaster forum. I read about some new product that use native USB communication, not serial port communication...

This is how I ended up with a HTC+TC4C. Then modded my fan outlet to blow out as much smoke as possible. Quite happy with the results. It has a learning curve but once you understand and see it you can adjust accordingly. Stuff the HT just doesn't tell you. I havn't got the urge to use Artisan yet though I have it, but think I need to reflash the TC4C for it to work. Instead I keep pricing out Sono's and sample roasters.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: jimbo on March 28, 2014, 09:51:28 AM
HTC+TC4C on order.  Stay tuned.  Installation looks a bit involved, and fortunately the Hottop is not my regular roaster so I'll be able to take my time and hopefully not end up with a boat anchor at the end.

Jimbo
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: jimbo on April 01, 2014, 06:35:03 AM
HTC+TC4C on order.  Stay tuned.  Installation looks a bit involved, and fortunately the Hottop is not my regular roaster so I'll be able to take my time and hopefully not end up with a boat anchor at the end.

Jimbo

Curious what some of you have used for the K thermocouples.  Where did you source them?  I'm looking at a couple of options on eBay, but thought I'd toss it out there.  Based on the write up it looks liek the bare wire ones are the best option.

Jim
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: az erik on April 04, 2014, 12:07:46 PM
HTC+TC4C on order.  Stay tuned.  Installation looks a bit involved, and fortunately the Hottop is not my regular roaster so I'll be able to take my time and hopefully not end up with a boat anchor at the end.

Jimbo


It's not that bad really, the most time consuming part is drilling the hole for the led and mounting the probes.

BWT here videos of my fan mod
Hottop exhaust smoke on Vimeo (http://vimeo.com/91006263)
Fan on 20% bt right about 350 on Vimeo (http://vimeo.com/91006487)
Videos of the exhaust
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: SJM on April 04, 2014, 01:05:27 PM
Has anyone figured out how to rig a mirror or something so that you can see the front of the drum and the control panel at the same time? 

Susan
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: az erik on April 04, 2014, 01:57:34 PM
Has anyone figured out how to rig a mirror or something so that you can see the front of the drum and the control panel at the same time? 

Susan
Once you have a TC4C why would you need to see the control board? It beeps, push a button continue :)

The lack of trier and power drove me out of the HT. You should be able to get away with a quick glance at either I figure. I honestly watch BT and smoke more than the drum.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: SJM on April 04, 2014, 02:10:57 PM
Has anyone figured out how to rig a mirror or something so that you can see the front of the drum and the control panel at the same time? 

Susan
Once you have a TC4C why would you need to see the control board? It beeps, push a button continue :)

The lack of trier and power drove me out of the HT. You should be able to get away with a quick glance at either I figure. I honestly watch BT and smoke more than the drum.

Makes sense, but as a beginner I'd like to be able to correlate what I am seeing in the bean color with what the temp is reading. 

Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: az erik on April 04, 2014, 02:16:59 PM
I agree. I actually roast looking at the window, but mostly due to my laptop being in front of it. It's dark on my patio so i don't get the ability to see color change really.

I can tell you this about the HT's temp reading, it's quite far off from what reality is. A BT probe will tell you a lot more. My BT can be 430 and the HT only registering 405.  I actually think sometimes the TC4C and all the feedback I get from it makes like a little more complicated past a certain point.

On another note perhaps a makeup mirror would be perfect. I've used my wife's in the past to find random tools in my engine bays :)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on May 09, 2014, 06:48:13 PM
I started a new thread to post usage details on the TC4C:
www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=17702.0 (http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=17702.0)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on May 11, 2014, 12:21:58 PM
I also run a stored profile on my Hottop B that overrides most of the automatic changes that otherwise occur. Those are when it kicks the fan up to 75% after a few minutes and later when it drops the heat to 80%. The idea of saving a profile is from this post by Randy Glass on coffeegeek ([url]http://www.coffeegeek.com/forums/coffee/homeroast/610920#610920[/url]).

If any of you have done this, please note - you MUST recreate the dummy profile with different settings (100% fan and 100% heat) for use with Jim Gallt's TC4C controller. This is clearly noted in the documentation by both Barry and Jim.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: RobertL on May 30, 2014, 08:49:52 AM
Danny Goot a roaster at SW's shared one of his Hottop profiles on their website. I find it interesting because it is exactly opposite of what I normally do. I've always thought it was best to give the beans full heat while the moisture content was high and then back off as they become dry. As you can see he starts off slow and turns up the heat as the beans become dry. I'll give his profile a try next time I roast and see how it works out.

Danny's usual starting point for his Hottop:

-200 grams of coffee (7 oz)
-Preheat until beeping stops, charge coffee and let it rip!
-Turn down to 40% heat through the drying period
-Back up to 100% until right before 1st crack then I drop to 80% heat.
-Sometimes I keep the heat at 100%... Whoa!

http://www.sweetmarias.com/library/node/9183 (http://www.sweetmarias.com/library/node/9183)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: fffolks on May 30, 2014, 10:08:45 AM
I had serious doubts, but I tried it anyway. Total fail. I reached yellow at about 15:00 with a variac holding at 120v. I dumped beans at 20:00 and they were about 5:00 or more from reaching first crack. I'm not sure how this profile is possible!
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on May 30, 2014, 10:23:43 AM
Agree with fffolks- That profile is the antithesis of what I have learned about the chemistry of roasting.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on October 22, 2014, 09:17:53 AM
I uploaded a 10 second video to show the NEW items displayed in artisan version 0.7.1. Near the top of the screen are three separate timers for
  • Elapsed time since turning point
  • Projected time to drying (BT 300 F)
  • Elapsed time since first crack
Temperature at turning point is shown at bottom of BT curve. Sorry, but my vertical axis starts at 160 F, and does not display it fully.

Edited 12/29 - corrected description of "drying time"

I just uploaded a much longer video about using the artisan software to replicate prior roasts. It is a bit hard to read the text in the video window below - click the youtube "graphic" for bigger version.

I made a few changes since the earlier video above:
I have profiles for about 15 coffees that produce good results right now. I am using artisan to monitor the roast progress post 1st crack, and make adjustments to match the prior time / temp target.

Artisan usage 10-21-2014 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W0nUV_uzEKw#ws)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on November 30, 2014, 08:08:29 AM
A new version of artisan (0.9) was released recently.
http://www.home-barista.com/home-roasting/artisan-v0-9-released-t33135.html (http://www.home-barista.com/home-roasting/artisan-v0-9-released-t33135.html)

It has several new features, including a "bean density" calculation - I haven't used it yet.
http://artisan-roasterscope.blogspot.de/2014/11/batch-volume-and-bean-density.html (http://artisan-roasterscope.blogspot.de/2014/11/batch-volume-and-bean-density.html)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on December 18, 2014, 07:01:31 AM
 
I've been playing around with my HotTop roaster top filter and bean roasting chute to get better heat retention. Several years ago I started a thread somewhere back in this forum about my insulation project. It's worked out nicely and this material is what I used to insulate the outside of the roaster.


[url]http://www.mcmaster.com/#9323k21/=pd7no1[/url] ([url]http://www.mcmaster.com/#9323k21/=pd7no1[/url])

I took some of this insulation and cut it into strips that could fit into the top filter to replace the material in there. I put two layers of insulation in there and it fit very well. I had also since the start of that insulation project just put a piece of insulation material on top of the filter and held it in place with a small wash towel. I wanted a cleaner solution and this seems to work really well after roasting tonight. For the bean chute I wanted to minimize smoke and heat loss out of the chute. I cut out a hole in a silicon baking sheet so the bean chute cover with my thermocouple probes fit snugly and taped it down with my heat resistant metal foil tape. That mod worked OK tonight and did minimize but not eliminate smoke coming out but I'm not sure about the longevity.

One preliminary finding is a hunch that the fan produced a more conductive effect on heat flow through the drum instead of acting totally like a brake on the roast.

I finally got around to insulating my Hottop - VERY pleased with the results. I was able to closely replicate a roast from July (80 degree temps) this past weekend (40 degree temps).

One minor error I made was in my choice of aluminum tape. It was not wide enough (only 1") and it would NOT stick to itself after the first roast!! I re-did my tape job a few times, and decided to order a different tape:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0026HVCPM (http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0026HVCPM)
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: smico on December 18, 2014, 07:56:41 AM
Can you post some pictures of your bundled up Hottop?
Thanks
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on December 18, 2014, 09:25:26 AM
Without the shiny tape, these are not so pretty. First one shows cutouts for bean chute, second shows both layers of insulation taped down, third shows how tape came unstuck after first roast.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on December 18, 2014, 09:32:47 AM
Here are the two roasts of 215g of Yirgacheffe (Bodhi Leaf 2012):
07-19-2014 roast hits 1st crack at 11:06, end roast at 13:30
12-14-2014 roast hits 1st crack at 11:15, end roast at 13:45

The second roast uses the first one as the background. It shows a higher ET throughout, which is due to the added insulation. The smoother ROR curve is due to changes in my artisan settings over the last 5 months.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: antoine_t on January 24, 2016, 05:59:40 PM
After a week or two of roasting with the variation of Randy's filter from the previous po,t where only paper filter is replaced with metal filter, I can say that I have removed one unpredictable variable from my roasting.
Roast after roast, some 15 batches, very consistent and predictable results.
Air flow at different levels is pretty linear, so I can actively use all fan settings.
I will need to find replacement for the cloth at some point.
Until I find replacement, I will be buying filters and replace paper with metal filter. If someone will need paper parts of the filters I will be giving them for free.

I recently bought an older P model (non K) and it didn't come with the rear filter holder at all.

 I have some folded up paper towel in there to act as a barrier.  Is that sufficient, or should I just purchase the rear filter holder?



also is the fan suppose to be blowing OUT from the back or blowing in towards the motor? 

Right now mine is blowing out but I am not sure if that's correct or not.  But if it blows in, the hot air wouldn't be able to leave the roaster?


thanks!
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: ptrmorton on January 24, 2016, 07:20:39 PM
The fan definitely blows out in the original configuration.  The filter protects the fan, the air you breath and somewhat restricts airflow.  Some feel the original filter changes air flow restriction as it becomes dirty and opt for a more consistent filter material. No filter would require a change in profile (as would different filtering materials), but it can be done if the opening where the filter holder is inserted is closed off. As far as filter materials go, besides metal mesh, some have used green scotch brite pads (with and without holders) to replace the filters with good results.   I'd be concerned that paper towels might be too restrictive and prevent the fan from drawing air through the roasting chamber.  Also, whatever material you use, it needs to be a fairly tight fit or the fan will just draw in air through the top of the filter holder opening.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: antoine_t on January 25, 2016, 05:35:30 PM
The fan definitely blows out in the original configuration.  The filter protects the fan, the air you breath and somewhat restricts airflow.  Some feel the original filter changes air flow restriction as it becomes dirty and opt for a more consistent filter material. No filter would require a change in profile (as would different filtering materials), but it can be done if the opening where the filter holder is inserted is closed off. As far as filter materials go, besides metal mesh, some have used green scotch brite pads (with and without holders) to replace the filters with good results.   I'd be concerned that paper towels might be too restrictive and prevent the fan from drawing air through the roasting chamber.  Also, whatever material you use, it needs to be a fairly tight fit or the fan will just draw in air through the top of the filter holder opening.


Okay i think i will buy the rear filter just in case then.


As for the fan, it's blowing outwards right now,  I looked at the paper towel i had stuffed in between and after 3 roasts, there is zero residue or discolouring!


I think i will save up a bit and go the htc tc4c down the line
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: ptrmorton on January 25, 2016, 06:55:05 PM
Quote
I think i will save up a bit and go the htc tc4c down the line

The geeky scientist in me is tempted by the tc4c as well, but I've performed other less expensive mods that are giving me a very satisfying roasting experience.  The tc4c would allow more consistency for sure, but I'm beginning to appreciate the art form of roasting more and more.  Either way, the HotTop is a blast to use.  Now if it just could roast larger batches.......  Down the rabbit hole I go.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on January 28, 2016, 08:01:24 AM
The geeky scientist in me is tempted by the tc4c as well, but I've performed other less expensive mods (look up RAF on Homeroasters.org) that are giving me a very satisfying roasting experience.  The tc4c would allow more consistency for sure, but I'm beginning to appreciate the art form of roasting more and more.  Either way, the HotTop is a blast to use.  Now if it just could roast larger batches.......  Down the rabbit hole I go.

I simply LOVE the TC4C on my Hottop - best upgrade ever! But I am sorely tempted by other roaster choices with bigger capacity (aka Huky (http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=18852.0)).

I get my best results on the Hottop with only 195g. I normally do 4 roasts each week, which takes about 3 hours (including cool-down). Sometimes it is hard to carve out that much time on a Saturday.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on January 31, 2016, 08:56:49 AM
I bought metal filter that fits perfectly on HT:
[url]http://www.suntekstore.com/goods-10008829-aluminum_filter_dust_guard_12cm_120mm_for_pc_case_fan.html[/url] ([url]http://www.suntekstore.com/goods-10008829-aluminum_filter_dust_guard_12cm_120mm_for_pc_case_fan.html[/url])

First I used only the metal filter, but resistance is very low, and roasting was even dependent on outside weather as my HT is connected to vented hood. 

Then I decided to put back original black cloth, and resulting filter gives very predictable results.  Soaking in cafitza returns filter 100% efficiency.  I will see how long the cloth will last.

I finally made this Hottop mod in December, and I am very happy with the results. I did not detect any change in the roast process, so I no need to change any profiles.

It is very easy to clean the metal filter material by soaking. I no longer have to worry about damaging the paper - or when to replace the paper filter material. As Miroslav said, "very predictable results", which makes me a happy camper.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on February 01, 2016, 11:40:09 AM
The geeky scientist in me is tempted by the tc4c as well, but I've performed other less expensive mods (look up RAF on Homeroasters.org) that are giving me a very satisfying roasting experience.  The tc4c would allow more consistency for sure, but I'm beginning to appreciate the art form of roasting more and more.  Either way, the HotTop is a blast to use.  Now if it just could roast larger batches.......  Down the rabbit hole I go.

I simply LOVE the TC4C on my Hottop - best upgrade ever! But I am sorely tempted by other roaster choices with bigger capacity (aka Huky ([url]http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php?topic=18852.0[/url])).

I get my best results on the Hottop with only 195g. I normally do 4 roasts each week, which takes about 3 hours (including cool-down). Sometimes it is hard to carve out that much time on a Saturday.


Like you I had been roasting using batches from 175 to 195 gm to get my best results. I bout a variac so that I could maintain adequate voltage year round and it has made all the difference. At full power and 118-119 volts (for reference) I get equally good roasts of 227 gm. The variac is a great tool that I would not be without any longer. Perhaps my ET's are a touch higher but I've never seen tipped or scorched beans. Just a thought for you to get more output.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on February 01, 2016, 01:49:34 PM
Like you I had been roasting using batches from 175 to 195 gm to get my best results. I bout a variac so that I could maintain adequate voltage year round and it has made all the difference. At full power and 118-119 volts (for reference) I get equally good roasts of 227 gm. The variac is a great tool that I would not be without any longer. Perhaps my ET's are a touch higher but I've never seen tipped or scorched beans. Just a thought for you to get more output.
+1
I have been using a variac with my Hottop from the beginning (back in 2012). It was necessary in the summer time, due to heavy power draw of our air conditioners.

My recent experiments with roasting greater loads did not make me happy - it just extends the roast "a bit too far". I'm probably a bit too picky, but to me the coffee is not quite as good:
230g took 11:40 for 1st crack, 14:10 total roast time
200g took 10:20 for 1st crack, 12:50 total roast time
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: ptrmorton on February 01, 2016, 02:05:42 PM
Quote
230g took 11:40 for 1st crack, 14:10 total roast time
200g took 10:20 for 1st crack, 12:50 total roast time

Curious, how hot is your charging temp and how long for your BT to get up to 300F or 149C?  My development time is very similar for 230g, but I reach 1st C right around 10 minutes.  I do use a variac and have insulated my roaster among other mods.  Thanks in advance.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on February 01, 2016, 04:10:48 PM
I dump the beans between 305 and 320 degrees (on the hotspot panel- about 350 or so on the ET thermocouple) depending on bean hardness. It takes 5-5 1/2 minutes to get to 300* bean temperature and first crack between 9 to 10 minutes with 227 gm beans
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: ptrmorton on February 01, 2016, 04:24:58 PM
Very similar.  Thanks.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on February 01, 2016, 04:35:03 PM
Turn temperatures on my bean temp probe are generally 175-185* and I keep the voltage at 118-119 when on full power. It is a very reproducible.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: ptrmorton on February 01, 2016, 04:42:09 PM
Quote
Turn temperatures on my bean temp probe are generally 175-185* and I keep the voltage at 118-119 when on full power. It is a very reproducible.

Interesting.  My turn temp is slightly lower (165-175), but we end up in the same spot after 5 minutes.  Lots of factors to account for that.  Thanks for the confirmation and information.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on February 01, 2016, 04:55:53 PM
My roaster is insulated. There is a whole thread on it from back in about 2010 or so. That could account for the difference.  As you stated there could be lots of factors affecting roast times.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: ptrmorton on February 01, 2016, 05:00:11 PM
Mine is also insulated, but I've reversed the air flow.  Actually, I'm impressed how similar they are.  Thanks again for the info.  Always looking for more knowledge on roasting!  I love it.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: GC7 on February 01, 2016, 08:44:23 PM
I had to replace the heating element last year. Perhaps that's part of the small differences we see in roast times? My top filter has insulation in it as well. I find our results remarkably similar and that is nice to see. The reverse flow interests me. I never thought the hottop utilized convection as well as it could-
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on February 02, 2016, 05:28:39 AM
Curious, how hot is your charging temp and how long for your BT to get up to 300F or 149C?  My development time is very similar for 230g, but I reach 1st C right around 10 minutes.  I do use a variac and have insulated my roaster among other mods.  Thanks in advance.
I too have insulated my roaster, and replaced the heating element in September 2015. I use a wide range of charge temps, anywhere from 225F up to 425F. The time to first crack varies widely for different coffees that I roast.

For this particular bean I charged at 275F:
230g load - hit 300 at 6:30, took 11:40 for 1st crack, 14:10 total roast time
200g load - hit 300 at 5:50, took 10:20 for 1st crack, 12:50 total roast time
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: ptrmorton on February 02, 2016, 07:38:50 AM
Quote
I too have insulated my roaster, and replaced the heating element in September 2015. I use a wide range of charge temps, anywhere from 225F up to 425F. The time to first crack varies widely for different coffees that I roast.

For this particular bean I charged at 275F:
230g load - hit 300 at 6:30, took 11:40 for 1st crack, 14:10 total roast time
200g load - hit 300 at 5:50, took 10:20 for 1st crack, 12:50 total roast time

Thanks.  Almost the entire difference in our roasting time is at <300F.  Probably due in part to my higher charging temp.  I appreciate the sharing as I'm always looking to improve my roasts.  I'll try cutting back on the batch size and lower my charge temp and see what happens, but my previous experience is that profile changes below 300 F aren't as crucial. as long as they are not too extreme.  Of course, my taste buds could be damaged from all those years of bad coffee before I discovered the joys of roasting! ;D
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: aletab on May 01, 2016, 12:01:24 PM
I've had my hottop for about a month and run 3-5 batches each weekend. So I am starting to get a handle on it and can get good roasts from it at this point. But one thing I still do not understand is the fan. I am using the standard paper filter.

I ran some experiments to get a feel for how quickly it responds to changes in heater (slow!) and fan settings. What is weird is that I see no difference between 10% fan and 100% fan. For example, if half way through a roast if I drop the power to 0% and watch deltaBT drop off – it drops off at the same rate with the fan at 10% or 100%. Or maybe it is subtly different but not enough that it is going to make a difference. I was hoping that I could get it to react faster by using the fan but that doesn’t seem to do what I expect.

Now I can see that part of the function of the fan is to clear smoke but shouldn’t it also draw outside air in and cool the environmental temp faster at a higher setting? Does this sound weird? Normal? Am I missing something?

I like this roaster a lot and using Artisan with alarm files is cool but I am mystified about the fan.
Title: Re: Hottop Profiles / Q&A / Tips & Tricks
Post by: rgrosz78 on May 01, 2016, 06:08:38 PM
I had a similar experience when I started with the Hottop. After experimenting a bit, I decided to follow the guidelines of the Hottop "manual". My standard approach is No fan until BT reaches 300. Then I increase the fan to 25%. About 2 minutes prior to 1st crack, I bump the fan up to 50%. Here is a graph showing my usual approach:
http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php/topic,19181.msg309707.html#msg309707 (http://www.greencoffeebuyingclub.com/index.php/topic,19181.msg309707.html#msg309707)

Most of the time I leave the fan at 50% through the end of the roast. For some beans, the roast will accelerate after 1st crack, so I continue to decrease the heat and roast, all the way down to zero.